Damiano Defense: Why is it one of the weakest chess openings.

The Damiano Defense is a chess opening beginning with the moves:

1. e4 e5
2. Nf3 f6?

The defense is one of the oldest chess openings, with games dating back to the 16th century. It is a weak opening that gives a large advantage for White after 3. Nxe5. Even if White does not go for this continuation, simple development leads to an advantage since 2. ... f6 weakened Black's kingside as well as took away the best square for the g8-knight.

History

The opening is named after the Portuguese chess author Pedro Damiano (1480–1544), despite the fact that he condemned it as weak. In 1847, Howard Staunton wrote of 2. ... f6, "This move occurs in the old work of Damiano, who gives some ingenious variations on it. Lopez, and later authors, have hence entitled it 'Damiano's Gambit'." Instead, Staunton's contemporary George Walker more logically reserved the term "Damiano Gambit" for the knight sacrifice played by White on the third move: 1. e4 e5 2. Nf3 f6 3. Nxe5. Staunton referred to [1. e4 e5 2. Nf3] 2. ... Nc6, a highly respected move then and now, as "Damiano's defense to the King's Knight opening".

The Damiano Defense is never seen today in top-level play. The greatest player to play the Damiano in serious master competition was Chigorin. As noted above, he played the 3. ... Qe7 line in a game against Schiffers at St. Petersburg 1897. Chigorin lost his queen on move 10, but Schiffers played so weakly that Chigorin later missed a brilliant forced mate and only escaped when Schiffers agreed to a draw in a winning position. Robert McGregor played the Damiano in a 1964 simultaneous exhibition against Bobby Fischer, essaying 3. ... Qe7 4. Nf3 d5 5. d3 dxe4 6. dxe4 Qxe4+ 7. Be2 Bf5, and drew, although Fischer did not play the best moves.

Because Black's weak move 2. ... f6? exposes Black's king, weakens Black's kingside and takes away his knight's best square, there's 2 moves you can use in this situation:

1. 3. d4 and 3. Bc4

The moves 3. d4 and 3. Bc4 are strong replies; Israel Albert Horowitz wrote (substituting algebraic notation for his descriptive notation), "Simple and potent is 3. Bc4 d6 4. d4 Nc6 5. c3, after which Black chokes to death."

2. 3. Nxe5!

Most forceful, however, is the knight sacrifice 3. Nxe5!. Taking the knight with 3. ... fxe5? exposes Black to a deadly attack after 4. Qh5+ Ke7 (4. ... g6 loses to 5. Qxe5+, forking king and rook, leaving Black down the exchange, though other options are worse) 5. Qxe5+ Kf7 6. Bc4+ d5! (6. ... Kg6?? 7. Qf5+ is devastating and leads to mate shortly with 7. ... Kh6 8. d4 g5 9. h5 Kg7 10. Qf7 Kh6 11. hxg5#) 7. Bxd5+ Kg6 8. h4 (If 8.d4? Bd6!) 8. ... h5 (8. ... h6 is similar, except Black cannot play 9. ... Bxb7 because of 10. Qf5#) 9. Bxb7! Bd6 (9. ... Bxb7 10. Qf5+ Kh6 11. d4+ g5 12. Qf7! mates quickly) 10. Qa5!, when Black's best is 10. ... Nc6 11. Bxc6 Rb8, and now White will be ahead by several pawns. Bruce Pandolfini notes that Black's opening is thus sometimes described as "the five pawns gambit". Alternatively, White can continue developing his pieces, remaining four pawns up. In either case, White has a clearly winning position.

Since taking the knight is fatal, after 3. Nxe5 Black should instead play 3. ... Qe7! (Other Black third moves, such as 3. ... d5, lead to 4. Qh5+! g6 5. Nxg6!) After 4. Nf3 (4. Qh5+? g6 5. Nxg6 Qxe4+ 6. Be2 Qxg6 leaves Black ahead a piece for a pawn) 4. ... Qxe4+ 5. Be2, Black has regained the pawn but has lost time and weakened his kingside, and will lose more time when White chases the queen with Nc3, or 0-0, Re1, and a move by the bishop on e2. Nick de Firmian in Modern Chess Openings analyses instead 4. ... d5 5. d3 dxe4 6. dxe4, when White had a small advantage in Emmanuel Schiffers vs. Mikhail Chigorin, St. Petersburg 1897.

Conclusion

The fact that Black can only regain the pawn with 3. ... Qe7! shows that 2. ... f6? did not really defend the e-pawn at all. Indeed, even a relatively useless move like 2. ... a6?! is less risky than 2. ... f6? After 2. ... a6?! 3. Nxe5, Black could still regain the pawn with 3. ... Qe7 4. d4 d6, when he would have done so without weakening his kingside or depriving his king's knight of its best square. Damiano Defense is common in scholastic plays, which could lead to disaster for Black if White knows how to counter the defense. It would be recommended to stop using this defense as this will give you a serious disadvantage and will effect your game later on.

I hope this gives you more understandings on Damiano Defense and why it's a bad opening to start with.