1 e4 ????

I have been winning much more games with the white pieces rather than the black pieces. I believe this is because I can get into an open/tactical middle game which is what I prefer to play. I am not so sure what response to play after e4 that turns into an open/tactical middle game. I am not a big of e5 because simply white has too many options which is really hard to be prepared for everything. For example, itailian game, ruy lopez, scotch game, vienna game, ponziani opening. I also believe white is very comfortable when black responds with e5. Perhaps maybe e4 e6 d4 c5? Any thoughts, comments, or ideas are highly appreciated.