Lobbying for Score graph presentation change

I have previously posted on this and it may be in the works but I thought I'd post this to get some feedback just in case  it isn't in the works.

The proposal is to have the move annotation icons by arrange color with white's above the x-axis and black's below. Below is a composed example contrasting the 2 approaches. Note the icons can be larger and more readable and one can easily see who made what kind of moves when,

Agreed 2

@jas0501  Good idea! 

I think it is a pretty good idea.

👍

yes!

I will ask our designer to check it out. Thanks!

That is a great idea

Very nice idea!

I like it, is there a voting location we can vote on ideas?

JD I'm curious regarding the designer's reaction to this suggestion. 

The proposal would be a significant improvement to the Score display and provide an easy unambiguous  way to review one's move via the Score graph as white's and black's icons are clearly separated.

Any hope we will see this improvement? 

It may be just me that feels strongly about the Analysis Report's Score tab presentation, but the elimination of the icon from the Score display and adding them to the mouse hover is a disappointment.

Below is a compose rendering that shows the previous approach, a proposed approach and the current approach. I would appreciate some user feedback, anyone care to comment?

Helloooo!? Is this thing on? Testing 1...2...3?

Am I the only one on the planet that thinks the new report analysis Score display with the hidden, hover activated, move classification icons is a mistake?

Hasn't anyone else used the Score display to get a clearer idea of the flow of the game and the good/bad move sequences and then click on the move icon to go to that board position?

As implemented now that is not possible. 

I apologize for the lack of response  

To be honest, the best I can offer right now is that we are heavy talks about analysis feature as a whole again an I will do my best to make sure your opinions are voiced as we have that conversation. 

I appreciate your response. I also appreciate all the fixes and improvements that have been implemented. Not lacking opinions here is my bullet list of topics/issues I would include in the Analysis Report discussions:

• the aforementioned Score display move classification icon presentation
• the Time presentation scaling as the most relevant aspect is the longest times spent on moves and this is lost due to truncation.
• the Theme presentation horizontal scroll bar issue
• the missing entries from the retry lists
• the missing clocks when at 100% zoom
• the board flip and/or retry context change lack of synchronization.
• the lost/missing retry count display of the current retry context when returning from the retry tab
• no field should be editable on the detail tab
• the addition of an editable private "notes to myself" summary field on the detail tab, displayable via hover on the archive listing so one can see a game recap
• ending clock times so one can easily see the game was lost on time. At the moment one has to move to the last move, and due to the zoom clock issue adjust the zoom to see the time left on the clocks

- the aforementioned Score display move classification icon presentation (I have decided to move these at this time. They are now available on hover, or, on the Best Move Diff chart, which is more related to this)

- the Time presentation scaling as the most relevant aspect is the longest times spent on moves and this is lost due to truncation. (agreed. ticketing to fix)

- the Theme presentation horizontal scroll bar issue. (already ticketed)

- the missing entries from the retry lists (we are going to keep hiding the ones that are near duplicates, or where you are already winning. if there is something else missing, let us know specifics - thanks!) 

- the missing clocks when at 100% zoom (I need more context on this one!)

- the board flip and/or retry context change lack of synchronization (I will look into this, but I don't immediately understand it.)

- the lost/missing retry count display of the current retry context when returning from the retry tab. (I also don't understand this.)

- no field should be editable on the detail tab (we are going to allow people to edit this, as it only impacts their OWN view)

- the addition of an editable private "notes to myself" summary field on the detail tab, displayable via hover on the archive listing so one can see a game recap (I like this suggestion! will ticket)

- ending clock times so one can easily see the game was lost on time. At the moment one has to move to the last move, and due to the zoom clock issue adjust the zoom to see the time left on the clocks (again, I don't understand this point. is this mobile web?)

erik, thanks for responding, I have referenced in bold forum topics that may explain things.

I see. Some of this is mobile web related... not sure how to address this yet, but thank you. 

To be clear, all my issues are with a PC, not mobile. I'm assuming the "mobile web related" comment is with regard to the code and conflicts PC vs. Mobile.