Multi-team Play

Sort:
Marignon

This is the topic to report those who play for multiple teams in the same competition.

Playing for multiple teams can become a very serious issue in this competition.

I remind the rules:

One player is not able to play for two different teams in the league for the same season (multi-teamer). If such case occurs in a match, all wins and draws scored by the multiteamer will be subtracted from match score.

The organisers have no responsibility for combatting multiteam play. Only those cases of multiteaming that are explicitely reported are taken into account for score recalculation.

For the lack of time I cannot check and report multiteamers in a constant manner.

However, I know that there are home-made software tools checking the presence of players in matches of multiple teams. 

If anyone can share it or take the responsibility for checking the matches of the competition, I will be very much obliged.

Marignon

Happy news at last!

Dale00007 has made a great gift to all of us by creating a tool able to parse Open Swiss matches and to detect those playing for multiple teams.

adriano81

Seems that Team Sevastopol is everywhere. I'm not sure if such Team has right to play in fair competition

Bland_Joe

Andrey-25

552362 Moscow Sevastopol
Bland_Joe
[COMMENT DELETED]
Marignon

Let's not jump to conclusions. This is purely technical information.

Let me remind the rules:

One player is not able to play for two different teams in the league for the same season (multi-teamer). If such case occurs in a match, all wins and draws scored by the multiteamer will be subtracted from match score.

The organisers have no responsibility for combatting multiteam play. Only those cases of multiteaming that are explicitely reported are taken into account for score recalculation.

Marignon

Until now I have not got any multiteaming reports (almost, there was one player mentioned by Rasht admin in Belgrade team).

That means that I have no absolutely reasons (and will not) recount for multiteaming players in already started matches.

However, all games in last two rounds and partly in this round will be processed with the tool - to guarantee that some players will not mob to promote their several favorite teams.

The tool has one nice advantage - it parses unstarted matches - that helps to check and remove multiteaming players in time.

Marignon

It will be also crazy to remove all above mentioned players entirely from games.

The team, for which the player started playing earlier or played more matches is a home team and will not bear penalties for using this player in final rounds.

If any player disagrees with home attribution, he will be able to leave a note in that topic and switch to another team.

Phoenix_Scorpion
BodaTajson and smiljko are playing for team Nis from the first round (that can be seen from this table also) so I do not understand why they are set as team Beograd players? Both players were contacted and decided to play only for team Nis, and such agreement is made with team Beograd admin also! That is why they are playing for team Nis in other rounds, too, and I believe they didn't play for team Beograd anymore, after mentioned agreement between those players and both admins were made.      
Marignon

OK. It is noted about BodaTajson and smiljko.

On a side note, Boda Tajson did play for Beograd in round 6.

I will change the table and republish it soon.

Marignon

List of players with duplicate entries

Round
ASC / DESC
Playername
ASC / DESC
Matchid
ASC / DESC
Hometeam
ASC / DESC
Playing for team
ASC / DESC
1 vitamin78 522374 St. Petersburg Sevastopol
1 Karandei 522374 Minsk Sevastopol
1 Sedoi2012 522374 Novosibirsk Sevastopol
1 artdo88 521764 Tirana Toronto
1 dark_bober 522164 Sevastopol Moscow
1 Biglittleboy 522162 Quebec Toulouse Occitane
1 smiljko 522162 Nis Beograd
1 BodaTajson 522162 Nis Beograd
1 pollovsky 522364 Queretaro Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK
1 lenormand14110 522532 Bordeaux Barcelona
1 CevdetOgut 522906 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
1 chessfanatic007 522906 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
1 gozgoz35 522906 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
1 kenthompson 523110 Bordeaux Paris
1 ru5200 522252 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
2 BodaTajson 531962 Nis Beograd
2 Karandei 525550 Minsk Sevastopol
2 GRVgeo 525550 Moscow Sevastopol
2 chessfanatic007 522910 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
2 gozgoz35 522910 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
2 LouisGuillotte 532308 Quebec Bordeaux
2 oge2013 532338 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
2 Vylvlad 532338 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
2 pollovsky 532338 Queretaro Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK
2 lenormand14110 531884 Bordeaux Barcelona
2 sester 531938 Toulouse Occitane Paris
2 kenthompson 531938 Bordeaux Paris
3 gozgoz35 538034 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
3 Kulinar 541568 Novosibirsk Moscow
3 Sa1ut 542470 Quebec Toronto
3 tizian24 542646 Moscow Sevastopol
3 Andrey-25 542646 Moscow Sevastopol
3 GRVgeo 542646 Moscow Sevastopol
3 Karandei 542646 Minsk Sevastopol
3 LouisGuillotte 542972 Quebec Bordeaux
4 smiljko 552388 Nis Beograd
4 Jararaca68 552516 Sao Paulo Barcelona
4 lenormand14110 552516 Bordeaux Barcelona
4 fan_de_federer 552706 Bordeaux Metz
4 ashkan176 552766 Rasht Berlin
5 Jararaca68 563436 Sao Paulo Barcelona
5 lenormand14110 563436 Bordeaux Barcelona
5 zhxtuw48 563436 Sevastopol Barcelona
5 khvs 563510 Sevastopol St. Petersburg
5 KpbIM_nyTuH_BogKa_ru 563510 Sevastopol St. Petersburg
5 philippegodon 563716 Paris Bordeaux
5 gozgoz35 564098 Istanbul, Fenerbahce SK Izmir
5 zhxtuw48 564098 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
6 filvlad 573030 Sevastopol St. Petersburg
6 BodaTajson 573038 Nis Beograd
6 malvolio62 573038 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
6 ru5200 573038 Sevastopol Novosibirsk
6 Jararaca68 573422 Sao Paulo Barcelona
6 smchess 573972 Bristol Rasht
6 ashkan176 578050 Rasht Berlin
Marignon

There is only one multiteam player - ashkan176 for Berlin in currently open matches.

I should thank Dale00007 once again for the powerful and flexible application.

Bland_Joe
Marignon írta:

Until now I have not got any multiteaming reports (almost, there was one player mentioned by Rasht admin in Belgrade team).

Andrey-25

552362 Moscow

Sevastopol

 

 

Marignon

 Moscow is this players home team. When he played for us in his first match. I made sure that he does not play for other teams. To track him further to check every other teams match is beyond anyone's ability.

Marignon

At least I try to do something with it. Joe, do you understand? 

If there were 5 teams from Hungary you'd have the same problem.

Bland_Joe

Is he a multiteam player or not, Marignon?

Against Beograd as Sevastopol player yes, againts Budapest as Moscow player not? I do not understand this.

You wrote you didn't get any report, I say you got from me. And you accepted.

Why he is not in the list with the 552362 match?

Phoenix_Scorpion

There must be a difference between player's first and second (third, ...) team. As your team's admin, you can not remove any player from other team's matches.

Marignon

I have made this list MYSELF. If you had come to be before the match I'd remove him. You did not. Now it is too late.

Now we can have zero multiplayers in last two rounds. It is very nice.

Bland_Joe

Strange....

Anyway I did in time, you can see on the match site. You removed two players, and I wrote immediately that there is a third one, too. You wrote sorry, i am right.

"Too late?" Where are a half sentence about the time in the rules? Again I ask something, and I do not get answer. Frown

I try again... Who is the multiteam player? What is the penalty? Andrey-25 is a multiteam player?

Why he is not in the list with the 552362 match?

Marignon

You suggest applying the rules literally.

OK.

I think that we could not apply this rule in the absence of a mechanism really checking all matches and so we cannot penalize any teans for multiteamers in first 6 rounds.

Our views differ.

You can submit a claim to the appealing committee and see their ruling. It is better to do this before Friday.