I think the engine broke. It's just a rook trade
The engine broke???
Sort:
TheSoldierOfTheNoobs
May 24, 2023
0
#1
kindhorse79 wrote:
I think the engine broke. It's just a rook trade
I think your brain broke...
May 24, 2023
0
#3
It is a bad move, but the explanation is kinda misworded. I think it means that you lose your only good piece, and will get rid of any chance of them blundering and a comeback.
May 24, 2023
0
#4
If you ever think there is a bug on an evaluation, it's best to include a link to the game and move number.
May 24, 2023
0
#5
kindhorse79 wrote:
I think the engine broke. It's just a rook trade
The engine apparently thinks that Qc6 is a better move. Still, it's very badly worded.
May 24, 2023
0
#6
Y'all didn't understand. He's black and he played Rd8, the engine says it blunders a rook; you can see it because the move he showed is by black, because it is Rd8, not Rxd8, and because the suggested line by Stockfish gives the first move to white
May 24, 2023
0
#7
angryspacevoid ha scritto:
to the 3 people above me (ok i meant that when i posted my comment i mean the 1st 3 comments after the OP) smh HES TALKING ABOUT BLACK's last move not white's
also Rxd8 wouldn't even be considered a mistake by the engine cause your down a queen + more already so it doesn't matter
but yeah thats weird
Exactly. Yeah, it broke
kindhorse79 wrote:
I think the engine broke. It's just a rook trade
It's saying that it's black's move that is a mistake, not white's move, as everyone is saying.
Running Stockfish 15.1 NNUE at depth 35 says that black's move 30.Rd8 is the best move, but the game review seems to be classifying it as a mistake. When you press show moves on the game review, it presents a line where white doesn't take back the rook. Strange!
Here's the link to the game: https://www.chess.com/analysis/game/live/78688224951?tab=review
May 24, 2023
0
#11
After Rd8 theres just a rook trade and black is up a queen and knight, how is that a bad move
May 24, 2023
0
#12
BishopBlessings ha scritto:
Seems too bad to be true, was that edited?
It isn't, there's the link
May 25, 2023
0
#13
Stock_Fish109 wrote:
kindhorse79 wrote:
I think the engine broke. It's just a rook trade
It's saying that it's black's move that is a mistake, not white's move, as everyone is saying.
I forgor to flip the board
May 25, 2023
0
#15
BishopBlessings wrote:
Seems too bad to be true, was that edited?
I'm too broke to get adobe photoshop lol. Its not
May 25, 2023
0
#16
lol, yeah really bad bug, game review giving incorrect information is not good
It's one of these positions SF cannot figure out at reasonable depth (yet). but if you analyze backwards (starting from end of the game) it finds rd8 was the best move:
-M8 30... Rd8 31. Rxd8 Qxd8 32. Kg2 Ke4 33. exf6 Qd2+ 34. Kh3 gxf6 35.
I thought it was like this
May 26, 2023
0
#19
The bug is not that it is classified as a mistake, but that it says that the move loses a rook. Just because Stockfish says that the best move is to let him have the rook doesn't mean it loses a rook.
