The following review has a number of flaws and errors. I have increased the font size a bit for easier reading and will comment on the content as it goes:
Hi Shelby,
I have had about three weeks of daily use with your new chess clock, VTek300.
Did you really play Chess with this clock every day for about three weeks?
While there are several things I liked about your clock, I found there to be MANY limitations.
For one, I absolutely HATE the fact that you need to go to the "master" settings to change out what the clock will function in. I was under the impression that you were able to have 20 customized favorites. The truth is you do not truly have 20 customized favorites. You have to constantly adjust your "master" settings to make your favorite work the way you need it.
To put this into perspective for people who have not used this clock, if you decided to set 5 different favorites as follows:
Fav 1 - G/10 Increment 30 - No Buzzer
Fav 2- G/25 Bronstein 5 - With Buzzer, Freeze Off
Fav 3- 40/90 20/30 G/30 Increment 30 starting from move 41 - No buzzer, Freeze On
Fav 4 - G/30 Delay 5 - No Freeze
Fav 5 - G/45 Increment 25
Do you really play with Bronstein instead of Delay? Most people I know use either the Delay or Increment. Bronstein is seldom used.
And as noted in another post by a NTD who also is a FIDE arbiter, the "Buzzer" is against the rules in all games.
How many tournaments use 3 time controls anymore? I have looked and very few do.
When in the United States we generally use the USCF settings. If you want to use the FIDE settings, then all you need do is go into the Preferences and Play Mode and make ONE change to either USCF or FIDE. There is no need to individually set the Freeze, Beep or other aspects.
Of course if you do want to set the individual things, you can use the Custom part of that Mode.
In practice and real play, the combination of Time Controls you have listed are not used in the same area or at anything like the same time.
The fact is that this clock is easy to set. I have used mine for something like 3 months, sure not daily but quite a bit nonetheless. My clock lives in the USCF mode, because the rated and even unrated events I play in all use the USCF rules and settings.
They made this clock very easy to set. They also kind of hid the options that would make a time setting illegal, like playing the beep. If you want all these little details, you will make the setting more complex and difficult.
You would expect that every time you turned your clock on and selected any of these favorites, they should operate in the way they were originally set. NO, it does not work like this!
If I were to play back to back games starting with Fav 2 then Fav 3, all the settings for Fav 2 will now carry on to Fav 3. What this means is Fav 3 will have Buzzer enabled, Freeze Off and when when move 41 is made, no increment, but instead you will have 30 second Bronstein... Can you imagine this scenario playing out in a tournament where the players or arbitor realize the clock isn't set with Increment but Bronstein?
Answered above.
Another thing about your clock that I am baffled about is the size. This clock towers over my Zmart and DGT3000 making them look like strawweights. This clock does not have a great "feel" to it while playing blitz. Tournament yes, blitz no.
So, you're complaining that this clock makes the other 2 look puny?!? Well, maybe this clock IS more substantial and the other 2 are puny. Think about it.
I have used my V-Tek 300 for all types of games, including Blitz. I have indeed compared it to the DGT 3000 and ZMF-II as well as both the Chronos GX and Chronos II. And I have had friends and Chess playing colleagues use them all as well, giving me their opinion of all the clocks.
No one has ever said the V-Tek 300 does not have a great feel to it for Blitz or any kind of Chess. In fact its feel is almost identical to the Chronos II and similar to the Chronos GX. And when given the choice of what clock to use for Blitz, everyone chose the V-Tek 300 and Cnronos II over the Zmart clock with touch sensors and DGT 3000 clock with its rocker arm buttons. Sorry my friend, but this assessment of yours is off.
This is a little off subject but you might want to check for the bug when you have play mode set to FIDE mode. Say you have time control of 90 minutes with 30 second increment. The initial time should not be 1 hour 31 minutes! Now try and adjust this time under the TD settings to have 1 hour 30 min 30 sec, it will not allow you to. After you have made a -30 second adjustment in TD settings it brings you back to 1 hour 31 minutes...
I'd expect a clock worth $150+ to be programmable in every dimension. That is either player can have different initial starting times, delays, increments, etc. This isn't the case with this chess clock.
I believe the above 2 problems have been addressed since the Beta versions came out. Shelby would have that information.
While my ZMart and DGT3000 chess clocks only have four user settings, I am able to adjust almost every dimension of these clocks and have it saved and retrieved when needed. Again, I do not need to go in and adjust the settings EVERY FREAKING TIME!
Once again, the settings don't need to be adjusted EVERY FREAKING TIME!
And now, since you apparently own all 3 brands and models of clocks, you can use the one you like best for each type of time control.
I personally use my Chronos II clocks for Blitz and casual play. I use the Chronos GX clock for when I want a smaller footprint clock. And I use either of my 2 V-Tek 300 clocks (my second one just arrived earlier this week) for time controls over G/20, d/5. For instance I am going to use my new clock with the writing on the front for our Monday evening, USCF rated, G/30, d/5 event in a couple of days. I'll use the original Beta version that is all black with no lettering for my slower games when I use a very nice wood board and set. It is more aesthetic without the lettering, for me.
wiscmike also seems to either have forgotten or has chosen to ignore something else, also. They decided to NOT have a cable connect port on the V-Tek 300 before they produced even the Beta versions. So there is no way to plug into this clock at all. If there is a program update or upgrade then the clock must be sent in to the manufacturer to have this done.
I'm sorry to tell the detractors, but this V-Tek 300 is indeed all that it was promoted to be. It is a great clock that is easy to set and use.
The only thing people, like wiscmike, can actually complain about is that it is too expensive. Well, it isn't too expensive if you are going to use the clock to actually play Chess with. It is worth it. The DGT 3000 and Chronos clocks are indeed worth the more money than those in that $50 range. And this V-Tek 300 is indeed worth the more money compared to those. The Chronos II currently lists for $115 - $120. The V-Tek 300 lists for $149. The features and quality of the V-Tek 300 make this clock objectively worth the extra $29 - $34.
And realize this clock is still really new on the market. I expect there to be sales down the line bringing that cost down as with all the other clocks.
I am posting this as a response to wiscmike. He currently has me banned because I pointed out that he was incorrectly complaining about The House of Staunton and their service as he bought a Chess set on clearance and they no longer had replacement pieces that matched the grain and color of the set he had. But, that's another story.
I have looked at and played with the Zmart Pro. I also currently own and use 3 Chronos clocks, 2 Chronos II and one Chronos GX. I also just purchased a second V-Tek 300 clock making it 2 of these that I own and use. I did sell my Chronos II touch and my last DGT clock to purchase this one.
Mike is wrong in that the Zmart Pro is an attempt to copy the Chronos clocks. The Zmart Pro is an upgrade of the ZMF-II clock. It has a metal body instead of the plastic one. The Pro also has an LCD display instead of the LED and a much larger size to the display.
The programming of the Zmart Pro is very, very similar to that of the ZMF-II. There are some differences, mostly in that there now is a choice of how the delay countdown is displayed.
The clock sets and operates almost identical to the ZMF-II. And a number of people have complained about that.
The display has the largest numerals in the market, perhaps too large. It also only shows one thing at a time on the display. The delay countdown only shows when the clock time is not present to see.
The body is aluminum like the Chronos and V-Tek 300, so there is durability in that.
Sales of this clock has not been stellar. Some of the reasons I have heard from a few retailers that I know include the display being too large, making the clock look more like a child's toy or a clock for someone that is visually handicapped. The limited information that can be displayed at any one time also is a detractor. With the Chronos being just a bit more expensive, people see no reason to buy this Zmart Pro.
Mike also seems flawed in his pricing information that he gives. While last Labor Day had Wholesale Chess with a big sale, giving the Chronos II for about $92 and the Chronos GX for something like $82, those prices are certainly hard to come by at this time.
The premier Chess set producer, House of Staunton, has these clocks listed at Zmart Pro - $100, DGT 3000 - $110, Chronos GX - $110, and Chronos II - $120. Of course there is the "always" discount of at least 10% here, but that certainly does not bring the price, including shipping to "well under $100".
Wholesale Chess has these clocks priced at, Zmart Pro - $98, DGT 3000 - $100, Chronos GX - $105, and Chronos II - $115. Once again saying that all these clocks can be had for well under $100 including shipping is a real stretch at best.
Having used and owned all the above mentioned clocks, except I have never owned a Zmart Pro but used one, I can say without a doubt that you do get what you pay for.
The V-Tek 300 is indeed the best of all these clocks. And yes it's definitely worth $40 more than the Chronos II.
The V-Tek 300 is the easiest to set and has the largest number of settings and time control variables. The body is aluminum and the buttons and controls are all durable and stable.
The display is, without a doubt, the best. The DGT 3000 has poor contrast compared to the others, while it does have lots of information on the display simultaneously. The Chronos has old technology but still has good contrast.
Mike, you haven't even tried out the V-Tek 300 to complain about the cost. Do you own a Chronos? Do you own a DGT 3000?
If someone is planning on spending in the $100 range for a Chess clock, spending a few more dollars, $40 - $50, is well worth having the best quality available instead of something less.