Stockfish 9's "Contempt 20"

Sort:
Avatar of TheTreeSurgeon

I am sad to see stockfish moving away from analysis (contempt 0) to winning games.

I suppose future progress, including the engine's internal "chess rules", "evals" and "whatevers", will now be built and tested against the currently "contemptuous" engine, compounding "optimism" into "delusion" !

Avatar of EscherehcsE

Ideally, it should let you set regular (playing) contempt and analysis contempt separately.

Avatar of TheTreeSurgeon

Still...

since contempt 20 has now become "master", any eventual "new" laws of chess "discovered" through the large statistical data sets of Fishtest will now be unreliably tainted by those pesky 20 centipawns !

Real shame !

Stockfish, the "poor man's" engine, was the closest thing to natural selection applied to chess apart from the reclusive Alphazero.

Shame the developpers succumbed to the pressure of only placing in TCEC and losing to the server farm that is Alphazero.

Avatar of TheTreeSurgeon

Yet another open-source project starts to care about its results...commercial aspirations maybe !? naaaaa

Avatar of EscherehcsE
TheTreeSurgeon wrote:

Yet another open-source project starts to care about its results...commercial aspirations maybe !? naaaaa

I could be wrong, but I don't see that happening with Stockfish. If they closed the source, they would lose most of the contributors to improvements.

Avatar of Crappov
EscherehcsE wrote:

Ideally, it should let you set regular (playing) contempt and analysis contempt separately.

I agree.  Maybe this will be implemented at some point.  For now, I have 2 configurations for Stockfish.  One with the default setting (contempt 20) and another with contempt 0.

Avatar of EscherehcsE
Crappov wrote:
EscherehcsE wrote:

Ideally, it should let you set regular (playing) contempt and analysis contempt separately.

I agree.  Maybe this will be implemented at some point.  For now, I have 2 configurations for Stockfish.  One with the default setting (contempt 20) and another with contempt 0.

Another option is to use Cfish 9, which has a separate "analyze contempt" setting that you can leave unchecked. Either way is good.

https://github.com/syzygy1/Cfish/releases

Avatar of Nordlandia

Default contempt of 20 is likely not ideal setting against opponent of equal strength, for example Houdini 6 and upcoming Komodo version.