1.e4 Openings HURT/HEAL Game

So how this works is there's a list of openings and in your post you can either HURT an opening by giving it -5 or HEAL an opening by giving it +5. (I'm going first as example)

If an opening gets to 0 points it's out and we keep going until there's one left, which is the winner. Each opening starts on 25 points. 

Rules: no posting 2 or more times in a row, wait until someone else has posted to post again

Openings: (alphabetical)

Alekhine 25

Caro-Kann 25

French 25

Italian 25

Modern 25

Pirc 25

Scandanavian 25

Scotch 25

Sicilian 25

Spanish 25

Hopefully this topic gets off the ground

Alekhine 25

Caro-Kann 25

French 25

Italian 25

Modern 20 (-5)

Pirc 25

Scandanavian 25

Scotch 25

Sicilian 25

Spanish 25

Cool idea, did you come up with it??

I'll hurt the modern too

Alekhine 25

Caro-Kann 25

French 25

Italian 25

Modern 15 (-10)

Pirc 25

Scandanavian 25

Scotch 25

Sicilian 25

Spanish 25

I saw a similar thing on another site

Alekhine 25

Caro-Kann 25

French 25

Italian 25

Modern 10 (-5)

Pirc 25

Scandanavian 25

Scotch 25

Sicilian 25

Spanish 25

make sure you write -5 not -10

I have nothing agsins

I have nothing against any opening so I am going to heal Sicilian

This is worthless - best defense to e4 isn't even listed.

i heal scotch 25+5 = 30

I see you mean the Petrov - I didn't want to add loads of 1...e5 branches when Sicilian, French etc get one branch

I will add Petrov and assume you heal it, I did think of it

updated

Alekhine 25

Caro-Kann 25

French 25

Italian 30 (+5)

Modern 10

Petrov 30

Pirc 25

Scandanavian 25

Scotch 30

Sicilian 30

Spanish 25

Me too tbh

Hurt Alekhine (25-5=20)

true true

hurt french (25-5 =20)

Healing the Sicilian 35+5=40

heal Italian please