Caro-Kann 25 (-5)
Italian 30
Sicilian 20
Adding @Sussyguy4890's vote to my post, which puts Caro at 10:
Caro-Kann 10 (-5)
Italian 30
Sicilian 20
I play the Italian as white and the Sicilian as black, so I definitely like both, but I'd keep the Sveshnikov Sicilian over the Italian if I had to choose one opening for my main repertoire. I could always switch to the Ruy Lopez or something with d4 without the Italian. I have been enjoying the Sveshnikov Sicilian quite a lot lately, so I'm trying to get the Sicilian to win.
Caro-Kann 30
Italian 30
Sicilian 20 (-5)