Explorer's best replies to KP 1. e4

All right, I continue my tests with top explorer lines (d=20):

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-openings/explorer-s-top-opening-choices-d-20

The comparison table (Explorer | ChessOK | Statistics) of best replies to KP 1...e4:

1. French | Sicilian | Sicilian
2. KPG | KPG | Modern
3. Sicilian | French | Caro-Kann
4. Nimzo | Nimzo | Nimzo
5. Carr | Caro-Kann | KPG
6. St. George | Pirc | French
7. Caro-Kann | Modern | Alekhine
8. Scandinavian | Alekhine | Pirc

1  line:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.09)

2 lines:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.14)
2. KPG 1...e5 (+0.23)

3 lines:

1. KPG 1...e5 (+0.13)
2. French 1...e6 (+0.36)
3. French 1...e6 (+0.29)

4 lines:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.06)
2. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.16)
3. KPG 1...e5 (+0.36)
4. Scandinavian 1...d5 (+0.58)

5 lines:

1. KPG 1...e5 (+0.20)
2. French 1...e6 (+0.24)
3. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.41)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.45)
5. inappropriate

 6 lines:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.21)
2. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.31)
3. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.33)
4. KPG 1...e5 (+0.40)
5. St. George 1...a6 (+0.44)
6. inappropriate

7 lines:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.17)
2. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.27)
3. Carr 1...h6 (+0.29)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.34)
5. KPG 1...e5 (+0.36)
6. Caro-Kann 1...c6 (+0.62)
7. inappropriate

8 lines:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.11)
2. KPG 1...e5 (+0.18)
3. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.34)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.35)
5. St. George 1...a6 (+0.41)
6. Pirc 1...d6 (+0.45)
7. Carr 1...h6 (+0.45)
   
8. inappropriate
   

9 lines:

1. KPG 1...e5 (+0.09)
2. French 1...e6 (+0.20)
3. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.23)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.37)
5. Caro-Kann 1...c6 (+0.44)
6. Carr 1...h6 (+0.45)
7. St. George 1...a6 (+0.50)
   
8. Scandinavian 1...d5 (+0.59)
9. inappropriate

Mean values of Explorer's evaluations:

1. French 1...e6 (+0.17)
2. KPG 1...e5 (+0.24)
3. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.29)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.37)
5. Carr 1...h6 (+0.40)
6. St. George 1...a6 (+0.45)
7. Caro-Kann 1...c6 (+0.53)
   
8. Scandinavian 1...d5 (+0.58)

ChessOK evaluations:

1. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.11)
2. KPG 1...e5 (+0.11)
3. French 1...e6 (+0.15)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.22)
5. Caro-Kann 1...c6 (+0.26)
6. Pirc 1...d6 (+0.26)
7. Modern 1...g6 (+0.26)
8. Alekhine 1...Nf6 (+0.26)
9. Scandinavian 1...d5 (+0.29)

Statistical evaluations:

1. Sicilian 1...c5 (+0.19)
2. Modern 1...g6 (+0.24)
3. Caro-Kann 1...c6 (+0.37)
4. Nimzo 1...Nc6 (+0.39)
5. KPG 1...e5 (+0.40)
6. French 1...e6 (+0.41)
7. Alekhine 1...Nf6 (+0.41)
8. Pirc 1...d6 (+0.46)
9. Scandinavian 1...d5 (+0.57)

The biggest surprise:

• Explorer prefers Carr 1...h6 and St. George 1...a6 to Caro-Kann 1...c6.

Sicillian! Or French Defense! Or Modern defense!