{Hurt Heal} King's Gambit Accepted Defenses

Sort:
ErnstStavroBlofeld1

Another hurt heal game.  This one is for the 10 most popular third move Defenses against the King's gambit accepted(3.Nf3 variation).

Heal your favourite Openings! Hurt the ones you hate!


Each opening starts off with 20 health. Every hurt deals 2 damage, whilst each heal restores 1 health. Once a opening reaches 0 health, it is ELIMINATED.

Rules

  • You may vote once every 12 hours - NO MORE! Any votes casted without waiting long enough should be IGNORED by other players.
  • You MUST repost the list of opening, stating which opening you have healed and hurt and UPDATE the scores on the list. Failure to do so will mean that the votes are NOT cast and should be IGNORED by other players.  Here is the list of King's Gambit accepted Defenses:
  • 1. Fischer Defense (3...d6)
  • 2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6)
  • 3.Classical Defense(3...g5)
  • 4. Modern Defense(3...d5)
  • 5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6)
  • 6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7)
  • 7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5)
  • 8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7)
  • 9. Becker Defense(3...h6)
  • 10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5)
ErnstStavroBlofeld1

Hurt Unnamed Defense

Heal Modern Defense

  • 1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
  • 2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 20
  • 3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 20
  • 4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 22
  • 5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
  • 6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
  • 7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 20
  • 8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 20
  • 9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
  • 10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 18
ThrillerFan

Uhm...Hello????  Your "Unnamed Defense" is ILLEGAL!

Heal Classical, Hurt 3...f5

  • 1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
  • 2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 20
  • 3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 21
  • 4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 22
  • 5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
  • 6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
  • 7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 18
  • 8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 20
  • 9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
  • 10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc4) 18

Mainline_Novelty

Heal Modern; Hurt f5

ErnstStavroBlofeld1

For the unnamed defense I meant 3...Bc5.  I will fix it.

ErnstStavroBlofeld1
  • 1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 21
  • 2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 20
  • 3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 21
  • 4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 25
  • 5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
  • 6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
  • 7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 14
  • 8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 20
  • 9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
  • 10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 16

Hurt Unnamed Defense

Heal Modern Defense

morganus

You forgot the Falkbeer :(

ErnstStavroBlofeld1
morganus wrote:

You forgot the Falkbeer :(

This list is only for defenses in the King's gambit accepted.  The Falkbeer Counter-gambit is 2...d5.

Oraoradeki
  • 1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 22
  • 2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
  • 3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 21
  • 4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 27
  • 5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
  • 6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
  • 7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 11
  • 8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
  • 9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
  • 10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 16

Heal Fischer, Massively hurt Schallop

I should add, its Fischer defense that made me switch from 3.Nf3 to 3.Bc4 when playing KGA as White.

Ben_Dubuque
Oraoradeki wrote:
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 22
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 27
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 11
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 16

Heal Classical hurt Fischer

 

Unlike you Oraordeki The fischer made me switch main moves to Nf3.

ErnstStavroBlofeld1
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 22
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 28
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 20
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 11
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 14
 
Heal Modern Defense
Hurt Unnamed Defense
ThrillerFan
Heal Classical, Hurt MacLeod
 
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 23
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 29
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 18
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 9
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 14
ponz111
ThrillerFan wrote:
Heal Classical, Hurt MacLeod
 
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 20
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 23
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 29
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 18
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 9
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 14

heal classical  now classical 24

hurt Fischer     Now Fischer 18

TheGreatOogieBoogie

Heal Fischer's Defense, hurt Gianitio Counter-gambit. 

ErnstStavroBlofeld1
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 19
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 24
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 30
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 18
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 4
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 12


Someone hurt the Gianitio Counter-Gambit but added one to it.  So the Gianitio Counter-Gambit should be at 4 health.
 
Hurt Unnamed Defense
Heal Modern Defense
Oraoradeki

For those who hurt Fischer's defense, will you care to give an explanation? Why is it unsound?

Ben_Dubuque
Oraoradeki wrote:

For those who hurt Fischer's defense, will you care to give an explanation? Why is it unsound?

it isn't that it is unsound, its that it just isn't convincing as a defense. g5 is much more testing, d6 also hems blacks dark squared bishop in, and essentially gives white what he wants in terms of center control development and tempo, and it does nothing about the f file preasure, check my study on the king's gambit for more, and then do some engine research. rybka even evaluates it as better for white.

Oraoradeki

Interesting arguments, but I like the Black side after this:

I'll be happy to take any questions. BTW the modern defense is only good because of this line:

which is tricky for White side to play.


Ben_Dubuque
Oraoradeki wrote:

Interesting arguments, but I like the Black side after this:

 

I'll be happy to take any questions. BTW the modern defense is only good because of this line:

 

which is tricky for White side to play.


in the first line whites play is innacurate



ErnstStavroBlofeld1
1. Fischer Defense (3...d6) 19
2. Schallop Defense(3...Nf6) 18
3.Classical Defense(3...g5) 25
4. Modern Defense(3...d5) 32
5. MacLeod Defense(3...Nc6) 18
6. Bonsch-Osmolovsky Defense(3...Ne7) 20
7. Gianitio Counter-gambit(3...f5) 0 DEAD 10TH PLACE
8. Cunningham Defense(3...Be7) 21
9. Becker Defense(3...h6) 18
10. Unnamed Defense(3..Bc5) 10


Hurt Unnamed Defense
Heal Classical Defense