Is there Anything Wrong with 2. Ne2?

Sort:
Avatar of Redendgame

Ive been analyzing this opening for days, and cant find anything wrong with it, in any variation. I have been playing games on Chess.com withit, and i have done pretty well with it. Why isnt it played? The main line:

Avatar of Redendgame

Here are some lines I have produced





Avatar of ItsEoin

Even though he's down a full pawn?

Avatar of pfren

White does not look being much worse after 3...Nxe4.

@ ItsEoin: which full pawn?

Avatar of Redendgame

A trap that may fool beginners

Avatar of Redendgame

I think ItsEoin means this:



Avatar of pfren
Redendgame wrote:

A trap that may fool beginners

So, you are a fool, or a beginner?

Make your choice please.

4...Nxe4?? 5.Qe2 Qe7 6.Nd5 (instead of your 6.d3??) wins at once.

Avatar of ItsEoin

I'd actually meant exf Nxf Nxe but partway through I realized that, like you say, that line drops a Knight. My bad. 

Avatar of pfren

This elementary trap may be just about the only good thing about 2.Ne2, but Black may not fall into it like a lemming.

Avatar of redfiredragon

see i dont see any game in my life that played ne2 this is bad really bad go for nc3 or nf3 but anyways the main moves after ne2 is bc5-d4-

Avatar of tyrannymutation

The "trap" reminds me of a line I've won with a half dozen times in the Vienna.  In fact if you want to play f4 in the open game 1. e4 e5 but don't want to play the King's Gambit, I recommend this opening to you instead, where you will still have the option of the active and customary Nf3 rather than Ne2?!

Avatar of Stampnl

Ne2 is allegedly called the Alapin opening and was featured in S.O.S. opening surprises vol. 4.  Why play 1.e4 opening lines for your queen and bishop only to close them again with 2. Ne2 tho. I lost a game against my cousin using this opening.

Avatar of Redendgame

@ pfren: I realize that the "trap" is not difficult to avoid, surely not at the master level. But as a rated 1350 player, it works quite well on my opponents. I surely wouldnt expect an international master like you to try this on one of your opponents. This opening should probably only be used by lower level players like I to attempt an early grab at the center with the F and possibly D pawns.

Ex.

Although Black obviously made some serious mistakes, this kind of thing happens more often than you would think in my games.

Avatar of Redendgame

btw, white is expected to castle queenside.