The annoying, prophylactic h6

Sort:
Se-Brain
I get annoyed by the fact that almost every game with my Dad, he plays h6 then short castle. Any way to counter this?
blastforme
You don't need to counter it. It's a weakness. Just develop your pieces then find and try to take advantage of it. the only downside is that you won't be able to pin his knight in the opening.

One idea would be to pin the g pawn and take the h pawn.. There are also interesting situations created when you pin the f pawn on the diagonal. Or sometimes if you're really well developed you can find a sound sacrifice. In any case, don't let that move bother you. If he's playing it every game, regardless of the position (as opposed to doing it for good reason , due to a specific position), then he's actually helping you out.
aljekhins_knife

Get the book "Logical Chess, Move by Move" by Chernev -- he's got plenty bad to say about such moves as h6.  Plus "at your level" I think you will generally improve from this book.

Casual_Joe

Just think of it as a wasted move by your dad.  Focus on getting your pieces developed and then annihilate him.

Pursuantspy

There is no direct refutation oh h6 in most positions however there in no need: it  weakens his pawn structure,wastes a tempo and makes his king more vulnerable. Solid development will most likely prove this o be a mistake. Don't misunderstand though in some positions h6 is strong, however it is definitely overplayed at the sub 2000 fide level.

Se-Brain

Here's an example of an opening stage:

 
aljekhins_knife
juliencebrian wrote:

Here's an example of an opening stage:

That's a horrible example, 3.Bd3 blocking White's queen pawn -- in fact he typically plays 3.d4 and then Black has no time for ...h6? or ...a6? as he is threatened with the loss of a pawn

pestebalcanica
pfren
eveningstarandlion wrote:

And what, g5? Then you want to do 0-0?

Yes, and no. ...h6 and ...g5 is a perfectly good solution in that particular position, and this is known since Stenitz.

Later on, lasker suggested that white should NOT play Bg5 in such positions before Black has castled.

Your 7.Bh4 is a second rate move. Taking at f6 and entering the so-called Canal variation is a better choice. With best play chances are equal, but both sides can play for more than a draw, or create a brilliancy:

Capa's handling of the endgame is a textbook example (despite the fact Capa was already past his prime).


pestebalcanica

Well, at least we are not Capablanca.

pfren
pestebalcanica wrote:

Well, at least we are not Capablanca.

Of course we aren't, but we always have something to learn from his games.

pestebalcanica

Blunder avoidance?

pfren
pestebalcanica wrote:

Blunder avoidance?

Capa occasionally blundered, as he was always playing very fast. However, these were high class blunders- most of the times his opponents did not notice.

But yes, you can learn the most by spotting yours, and your opponents blunders, and analysing them.

chessneon

Sometimes h6 is a weakness, but other times it can be quite helpful; one thing is that it creates "luft" for your king.

Jenium

One way is to castle on the opposite site and start a pawnstorm, when h6 is a target that makes it easier to open files.

Rarely it is also possible to sacrifice a bishop or a knight on h6 to open files.

Se-Brain

As I have been slowly improving in chess, I learned good attacks against h6, like this game:

dfgh123

capablanca calls it an excellent position in his chess primer, he even says it is as good as if not better than an untouched castled position against average players

BlunderLots

The three pawns by the castled king are like the king's bodyguards. The further they move away from the king, the more vulnerable he often is.

This is why you'll often see, in high-level games, the attacking player trying to provoke his opponent into making a pawn move on the kingside—it can often turn into a weakness, or even the target of a knight or bishop sacrifice, to blow open the kingside. :D

... h6, too, can be especially dangerous for black when white castles queenside.