Top five best players ever who were never world champion?

Sort:
Avatar of checkmateibeatu

Who do you think are the top five best players never to be world champion?  Feel free to vote, and show the games of and why you voted for who you voted for! (As always, make serious votes.)

The scoring system:

#1- 5 points

#2- 4 points

#3- 3 points

...and so on.

Current Poll Leaders as of 8/24/2011 12:53 PM PST (post 87)

Keres 44.5

Korchnoi 29.5

Morphy 29

Rubinstein 28

Bronstein 25

Carlsen 15

Pillsbury 10

Nimzowitsch 10

Polgar 5.5

Mecking 5

Geller 4

Polugaevsky 4

Reshevsky 4

Ivanchuk 3.75

Marozsky 3.75

Tarrasch 3.75

Najdorf 3.75

Larsen 2

Nigel Short 2

Karjakin 1

Charousek 1

Chigorin 1

Avatar of checkmateibeatu

By the way, you don't have to do 5, you can do less. Just don't do more than 5 please.

Avatar of ChessMarkstheSpot

  It's been agreed over the many years that Paul Keres was the best player ever to have never become World Champion.

   -Mark

Avatar of checkmateibeatu
checkmateibeatu wrote:

By the way, you don't have to do 5, you can do less. Just don't do more than 5 please.


Although it would be better to do 5.

Avatar of chessmaster102

Henry Nelson Pillsbury Quite surprised no one has said his name.

Avatar of angrychess

Nimzowitsch

Avatar of duskrevival

Deep Blue- 5

Shredder-4

Deep Fritz-3

Rybka-2

They were never world champions and they are pretty good players.

Avatar of kwaloffer

Carlsen

Avatar of checkmateibeatu
duskrevival wrote:

Deep Blue- 5

Shredder-4

Deep Fritz-3

Rybka-2

They were never world champions and they are pretty good players.


I mean among humans.

Avatar of Lokaz

Korchnoi

Keres

Carlsen

Larsen

Karjakin

Avatar of checkmateibeatu
[COMMENT DELETED]
Avatar of cubbie

1. David Bronstein

2. Paul Keres

3. Rubinstein

4. Paul Morphy

5.Korchnoi

Avatar of IArtemi

no one says Tal? it' s incredible, the most creative chess player ever, after him goes rubinstein , then alekhine, pillsbury and charousek.

1, Tal

2,Rubinstein

3.Alekhine

4,Pillsbury

5,Charousek

Avatar of duskrevival
checkmateibeatu wrote:
duskrevival wrote:

Deep Blue- 5

Shredder-4

Deep Fritz-3

Rybka-2

They were never world champions and they are pretty good players.


I mean among humans.


Racist.

Avatar of JJUlysses
AREtyom wrote:

no one says Tal? it' s incredible, the most creative chess player ever, after him goes rubinstein , then alekhine, pillsbury and charousek.

1, Tal

2,Rubinstein

3.Alekhine

4,Pillsbury

5,Charousek


Tal was world champ in 1960. 

Avatar of madhatter5

1. Mecking

2. Polugaevsky

3.Kortchnoi

4. Carlsen

5. Keres

Avatar of madhatter5
AREtyom wrote:

no one says Tal? it' s incredible, the most creative chess player ever, after him goes rubinstein , then alekhine, pillsbury and charousek.

1, Tal

2,Rubinstein

3.Alekhine

4,Pillsbury

5,Charousek


Alekhine was also a world champ, I believe

Avatar of checkmateibeatu
duskrevival wrote:
checkmateibeatu wrote:
duskrevival wrote:

Deep Blue- 5

Shredder-4

Deep Fritz-3

Rybka-2

They were never world champions and they are pretty good players.


I mean among humans.


Racist.


If this was including computers, than it would be pretty obvious that the computers would win.  Therefore, I did it among humans.

Avatar of hic2482w

I'm always surprised that Morphy was never WC, despite only being active for a short period of time.

Avatar of checkmateibeatu
hic2482w wrote:

I'm always surprised that Morphy was never WC, despite only being active for a short period of time.


Didn't the WCC not exist when Morphy was around?