Eagle chess: BISHOP_e3 vs. JohnHS

Sort:
BISHOP_e3

I have a rule inquiry. After I played 7) Hxg2, I had to drop the Bishop on move 8 or 9 correct? If that is true, then I have forfeited my right to drop the Bishop--Correct?

JohnHS

Yes, you did have to drop it ...

I didn't think of that.  Either the moves since then have been illegal, or your bishop is dead ... what do you think?

BISHOP_e3

I forgave your time violations, I was wondering if you could forgive my drop rule violation.

If you are willing to forgive, I am asking that the diagram be reset to move 9 with White to move.

If you are unwilling to forgive, I will accept your decision without complaint or bitterness.

Thank you, Be3

JohnHS

You can certainly take those moves back.  grin.png 

But in other cases,  what do you think?  Are those moves illegal and must be taken back, or do you lose the piece?

You mean B@e3?

 

BISHOP_e3

Thank you for the reset to move 9 with white to move.

In the future I think the rule should be that whoever captures his own chess piece (or pawn), and fails to drop it in the next two moves when legally possible, loses the piece (or pawn). 

I don't think that a player should be made to drop because it might be in the players' interest not to do so.

Be3 = BISHOP_e3 = A Bishop already residing on e3, OR, A Bishop move to e3.

In post #45 it was simply a signature.happy.png

BISHOP_e3

Move #9 ------- White to move

null

JohnHS

OK then, where do you want to put your other bishop.

BISHOP_e3

9) *Bg5*

JohnHS

9. ... f6

null

BISHOP_e3

10) Bxh6

JohnHS

10. ... ixh6  Sound odds when you say it out loud.  "Bishop captures h-six".  "No, ah captures aitch six" (wink.png) depending on your accent.

null

BISHOP_e3

11) Bxh6

HorribleTomato

Hey bishop! Would U like 2 join the bulldog tourney? Go to https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess960-chess-variants/looking-for-opponents-games?page=17

and send a message that you would like to join if you want to. We could use some more players and you seem like a variant player tongue.png 2 more slots open

HorribleTomato

It's similar to eagle

JohnHS

Good idea, Tomato.  Bishop, you should join.  It's a good tournament, though I got eliminated already.

11. ... Rf7

Must you beat me at my own game?  My  position is awful.

null

 

BISHOP_e3

12) Hxd5

JohnHS

12. ... Bxh3

BISHOP_e3

Hello John, I hope you are having a pleasant Monday. Would you please provide an updated board?

Thanks! 

JohnHS

Certainly!  Apologies, I was busy earlier.

null

BISHOP_e3

Thanks. 

13) ixh3