The odd game out

Sort:
zankfrappa

We need more hints.

Crazychessplaya

All right, here are some hints:

1) One of the games was called "the greatest masterpiece ever created on a chessboard" by a well-know American chess book author

2) Another was called "a masterpiece for the ages" by a guy named Yasser

3) A 17-move miniature (not the Morphy game) is yet unsolved

I hope this helps...

Crazychessplaya
Fiveofswords wrote:

well im too lazy to check but I would assume the one with 2 queens was in some totally constructed alekhine game...he pretended it occured but it never did...all i remember was that it was crazy and there ended up being a lot of queens on the board. Might end up being the odd one out in fact.


 No, the games chosen are all legitimate, including the 2-queen ones...

Crazychessplaya

Yes, it is 3 out of 3 for NM tonydal who is now the top solver!

Mainline_Novelty

...and the 17 move game... still unsolved?

Crazychessplaya

All correct, NM tonydal!

Crazychessplaya
tonydal wrote:

OK, I can't figure out any of the others.  The best I can do is guess that Nimzovich was White in VII and Alekhine was Black in XI (he's just played Qxf3 with a R on g8).


 I'll give you a hint, in both VII and XI we have the same world chess champion, but he is losing in one game and winning in the other. Neither Alekhine nor Nimzowitsch are players in the two games.

Crazychessplaya

One more hint: one unsolved game was called "X's Immortal" on the chessgames.com site, where X is a world chess champion's surname.

Murrrrr

The last one is Kasparov's Immortal. Garry Kasparov vs Veselin Topalov

Crazychessplaya

Yes, XVI is Kasparov vs. Topalov

Crazychessplaya

Hint for IX:

Both players are nationals of a mid-sized European country. Neither player was ever a world chess champion.

Crazychessplaya
tonydal wrote:

Btw is the "odd game out" one of the solved ones? (or are you at liberty to disclose this yet?). :)


I can't disclose it just yet. 

Murrrrr
tonydal wrote:
Murrrrr wrote:

The last one is Kasparov's Immortal.


Like the guy only had one...lol


Well that's recorded as Kasparov's Immortal, but yeah, he has played more than one game you could call Immortal

Crazychessplaya

A bunch of hints for the unsolved VII, IX and XI:

1) The games were played in 1984, 1976, 1977, and the order does not necessarily correspond to the games listed

2) At least one game was played in Las Palmas

3) A player losing at least one game was named Lajos (first name)

Crazychessplaya

A hint for VII: A former world chess champion tried the French Defence only twice in his career (which spanned decades, by the way). VII is a fragment of one of the two games.

boymaster

YES!!!!! NO MORE SOLVER!!!!!  YES!!!!!!!

Crazychessplaya

All right, more hints for VII, IX and XI...

1) One game was dubbed "Efimeral Advantage" on chessgames.com

2) In one of the games, the losing player's first name is Stefano

3) Some fans believe that"the greatest queenless combination ever played" took place in one of the three games

Hope this helps...

zankfrappa

One of them is Geller-Karpov from 1976 but I am having trouble matching
the game to your diagram.

Crazychessplaya
zankfrappa wrote:

One of them is Geller-Karpov from 1976 but I am having trouble matching
the game to your diagram.


 Correct! Now we're getting close to the final...

Crazychessplaya

One of the three is Geller-Karpov. Which one?