What would be your move

Sort:
Avatar of basketstorm
Black to move. What would be your move, explain without using the engine. I'm interested in real human reasoning, not in engine evaluation. I need this for my little research.

Avatar of basketstorm
TheNameofNames wrote:

take the dsquared bishop

WHY

Avatar of Mannequin08

Rf1

Avatar of Mannequin08

No no Rf3

Avatar of basketstorm

@Mannequin08 , delete your comments please, there's X button

Avatar of NitroOneX

NxBe3 because the problem with Rc1 is that it's being defended by Be3, if you remove the defender, he's forced to take with pawn and you can slide Rc1, pinning the queen

Avatar of Asnitte

1...Nxe3 2.fxe3 (otherwise lose a queen) Rc1

Avatar of basketstorm

Idk I understand that the engine prefers Nxe3 and that might be good strategically but to me Nc3 looks much more interesting and straightforward - making a fork, winning a rook

Avatar of nklristic
basketstorm wrote:

Idk I understand that the engine prefers Nxe3 and that might be good strategically but to me Nc3 looks much more interesting and straightforward - making a fork, winning a rook

Let's see the starting position. Black is a piece up for a pawn. d5 knight is attacked 2 times. Let's say black doesn't see the tactic but notices that the knight will be lost if something isn't done with it. So, I don't know, something passive like Ne7.

Why am I talking about this pretty sub par move? Because with that move black is still winning.
So any move that wins further material is winning more easily. But any further gain of material is diminished.

With Nc3, you win an exchange. Queen doesn't have to go to b1 to defend the rook. Nc3, then Qb3, Nxb5, Qxb5 is an exchange. In the end position you are a rook up for a pawn. That is 4 points of material more.

Nxe3 is a check and it attacks a queen, so white has to take. This is a relatively simple removing of the defender tactic. Now Rc1 wins the queen for the rook. In the end position you have a queen and the knight for a rook and the pawn. That is 6 points of material more. Plus it leaves less material on the board for white and gives him less chances. On the other hand, it kind of disbalances position which is better if you are trying to get back from a lost position.

Still less material on the board means more simplicity in most cases, so with more material gain along with it, Nxe3 is better. But as I've said, both are very good.

Now one more thing. If the position at the start was equal, Nxe3 would be much better than Nc3, because queen for the rook is much easier to win than simply with an exchange up.

Avatar of NitroOneX

It's not a bad move by any means but you win less material that way.

Avatar of AngusByers

Nc3, forking the Queen and Rook. The only square the Queen can go to in order to protect the Rook is b3 (the Knight covers b1), and NxR QxN puts them down the exchange (as QxQ leads to NxQ, and Black is up a full rook). Black can then capture the a pawn with their Queen, giving them the only Queenside pawn, and good open files on that side for their rooks to infiltrate on and/or give aid to the Black a pawn to start creating a worry for white.

Avatar of Kotshmot

Is this some Kramnik style research to see if the engine move is obvious for a human? It is obvious here, nxe3 wins the most material following up with pinning the queen. The other option nc3 is met with qb3 losing only the exchange for white.

Avatar of AngusByers
Kotshmot wrote:

Is this some Kramnik style research to see if the engine move is obvious for a human? It is obvious here, nxe3 wins the most material following up with pinning the queen. The other option nc3 is meat with qb3 losing only the exchange for white.

Oops, yes, Nxe3, I missed that the rook is now free to go to c1.

Avatar of nklristic

Yeah, you can even win that pawn after Nc3. So it is only one point of material difference. 
But as I've said, the problem of the position is that everything is winning. Even with a sub par move like Ne7, it is winning because of the starting material advantage and the weakness of the white king.

So the starting advantage is even more pronounced than a piece for a pawn (which in itself is winning).

Avatar of ChessEnthusiast48
1. Nxe3+ fxe3 now White’s backrank is weak
2. Rc1 wins the queen and the game
Avatar of Mid-KnightRider
basketstorm wrote:
Black to move. What would be your move, explain without using the engine. I'm interested in real human reasoning, not in engine evaluation. I need this for my little research.
 

I would take the bishop if they recapture we pin the queen with the rook.

Avatar of DoYouLikeCurry

Pretty simple tactic - taking the bishop removes the defender of rhe c1 square. Opponent can either lose material by not recapturing or lose material due to the skewer if they do.

Avatar of Kergat-boi

Qc1, isn’t it obvious?📙🕝

Avatar of basketstorm
Kergat-boi wrote:

Qc1, isn’t it obvious?📙🕝

No, that's not a move.

Otherwise thanks for the answers, really good explanations especially @nklristic

Avatar of Kergat-boi

YES IT IS

Avatar of Guest3885870136
Please Sign Up to comment.

If you need help, please contact our Help and Support team.