How to crush the Nimzo!

Sort:
Avatar of adumbrate

I am white, playing on another site.
Qc2 Nf3 is powerful, and often slightly surprising to the Nimzo player

Avatar of adumbrate

Cool

Avatar of adumbrate

Not as good as the first game, but it shows what to do if black replies with f5 after the usual stuff.



Avatar of adumbrate

no comments Yell

Avatar of adumbrate

do you guys agree that nimzo is a horrible opening??

Avatar of ArgoNavis

No.

Avatar of Diakonia

Lets examine the evidence:

"is the Nimzo a horrible opening?

1. This hypermodern opening was developed by Grandmaster Aron Nimzowitsch, one of the best players in the world.  

2. The Nimzo-Indian is a highly respected defence to 1.d4, is played at all levels and has been played by every world champion since Capablanca.

Now lets look at the other side:

1. An online bullet player that has lost more games than they won, proclaims the nimzo is a horrible opening, and is crushed.

 

Im going with one of the best players in the world, and every world champion since Capa.  Maybe its just me...

Avatar of pfren

5...c5 and 5...b5 are more usual responces. If Black wants to play ...b6, he might well play it at move four.

Avatar of ArgoNavis

This reminds me of the 789,123,456,789 other threads on "[Insert random opening] refuted!!!!"

Avatar of Diakonia
kingofshedinjas wrote:

This reminds me of the 789,123,456,789 other threads on "[Insert random opening] refuted!!!!"

<AHem> I believe its 670,975,221,098,370

Avatar of ArgoNavis
Diakonia escribió:
kingofshedinjas wrote:

This reminds me of the 789,123,456,789 other threads on "[Insert random opening] refuted!!!!"

<AHem> I believe its 670,975,221,098,370

Some of them were deleted.

Avatar of Diakonia
kingofshedinjas wrote:
Diakonia escribió:
kingofshedinjas wrote:

This reminds me of the 789,123,456,789 other threads on "[Insert random opening] refuted!!!!"

<AHem> I believe its 670,975,221,098,370

Some of them were deleted.

Thats right...by bad <over bite>

Avatar of thegreat_patzer

while I doubt you've refuted the nitzmo- you

have shown so great examples for white on how  to play with Nf3 Qc2 & Be4.   Ty

Avatar of pfren
Chess_Impress wrote:

Anand tried to crush Carlsen's Nimzo, but he did not succeed. But what a game it was!
https://youtu.be/sjOZBfseLPo

Black was dead lost in that game.

Avatar of chesster3145

Wow. There are some YouTube lectures titled "Crush this opening", even though the opening in question is fully sound. I agree that 4. Qc2 O-O 5. Nf3 is promising, but what do you do against 4... d5?

Avatar of Diakonia
chesster3145 wrote:

Wow. There are some YouTube lectures titled "Crush this opening", even though the opening in question is fully sound. I agree that 4. Qc2 O-O 5. Nf3 is promising, but what do you do against 4... d5?

Whenever you see a opening videos, books, software, etc. and it contains any of the following: "Crush", "Defeat", "How to Win", "How to Beat the...", "The Best...", "Mastering", "Ferocious", "Beating".  It will usually be crap.  

Avatar of chesster3145

@Lucia243:

Agreed!

They just made one about gambits. How much worse can it get?

It's about time people learned that chess and sales pitches don't mix.

You can't make an opening good just by saying that it is.

A move is either good or it isn't.

Avatar of pfren
Lucia243 wrote:
I might be mistaken but why does the opponent play b6? Isn't the main line c5? I don't know much about the Nimzo but b6 allows e4 and Bd3 and also to kick away the knight who serves as defender of the King with e5

4...0-0 5.Nf3 c5 6.dxc5 Na6 7.g3 leaves white with some chances of an opening advantage, and the same goes for the Hedgehog setups after 6...Bxc5. Black's soundest and most theoretical reply is 5...d5.

Black can play ...b6 one move earlier: 1.d4 Nf6 2.c4 e6 3.Nc3 Bb4 4.Qc2 b6! is probably white's main concern currently in the 4.Qc2 variation.

Avatar of adumbrate

After 4.. b6 I would play e4. And if you play d5, the same as in this variation.

However, 5.. c5 is much more interesting



Avatar of pfren
Varo2001 wrote:

youre opponent played 4.b6 , i think best move in 4.Qc2 is 4.d6, this move give black side more chances :)

Both 4...d6 and 4...b6 are interesting moves.

GM Gustafsson in his Qc2 Nimzo videos considers the continuation at #23 rather harmless because of 6...Qe7, with nthe idea of ...exd5, when white has to spoil his ideal pawn structure and take back at d5 with the e-pawn. In practice, Black has faced a few quick disasters after greedily going for a ...Ba6- Bxc4 plan, which allows white a very dangerous initiative- but if Black plays sane chess, the game is more or less equal.