I pick both so that I win those entire replies
And I pick Kasparov, who's better than both of them!
you only have one and I have two,how can one guy defeats two guys in one time
Well, maybe Kasparov could defeat Tal and Alekhine together in a simul? But just in case he can't, and since we're allowed to pick as many guys as we want, I'm also taking Fischer, Capa, Lasker and Carlsen. Looks like I win.
I pick both so that I win those entire replies
And I pick Kasparov, who's better than both of them!