Are you better as Black then White?

Sort:
EternalChess

Is any1 here  better as black then white in chess?

I am certainley most not, i tie more games with black then white but i lose more with black then white, and i play longer games with black.

 

  Wins Losses Draws Games Moves
Total 40 (71%) 8 (14%) 8 (14%) 56 1309
White 23 (82%) 3 (11%) 2 (7%) 28 (50%) 609 (47%)
Black 17 (61%) 5 (18%) 6 (21%) 28 (50%) 700 (53%)
ericmittens

Yup, Over the Board my performance rating when playing black is about 100 points higher than my actual rating. Consequently, my performance rating when playing white is about 100 points less than my actual rating!

Strange stuff, to fix this I'm drastically changing my whole white repertoire.

EternalChess

ouch,

i need to get better as black, but idk white is better because they get first move but black can always counter

Kernicterus

I have no idea.  

EternalChess
AfafBouardi wrote:

I have no idea.  


 

  Wins Losses Draws Games Moves
Total 258 (36%) 418 (59%) 35 (5%) 711 19538
White 133 (38%) 203 (58%) 16 (5%) 352 (50%) 9941 (51%)
Black 125 (35%) 215 (60%) 19 (5%) 359 (50%) 9597 (49%)
GMoney5097

Online: 

Wins Losses Draws Games Moves
Total 28 (44%) 35 (55%) 1 (2%) 64 1956
White 15 (44%) 18 (53%) 1 (3%) 34 (53%) 1053 (54%)
Black 13 (43%) 17 (57%) 0 (0%) 30 (47%) 903 (46%)

 

Live Long:

 Wins Losses Draws Games Moves
Total 277 (45%) 289 (47%) 52 (8%) 618 17861
White 144 (47%) 136 (45%) 24 (8%) 304 (49%) 9241.5 (52%)
Black 125 (45%) 132 (48%) 18 (7%) 275 (44%) 8619.5 (48%)

 

I don't really play blitz or quick, so those would be too small of a sample size.

 

So I guess I'm slightly better as white, but not by much.  The percentages are almost identical!

Kernicterus

Oh ok.  Looks like I'm about even with both.  No wonder I don't feel much difference.  I guess higher rated players feel the difference of the advantage of White more.  

Scarblac
ericmittens wrote:

Yup, Over the Board my performance rating when playing black is about 100 points higher than my actual rating. Consequently, my performance rating when playing white is about 100 points less than my actual rating!

Strange stuff, to fix this I'm drastically changing my whole white repertoire.


Is the problem with your repertoire, or your state of mind during the game?

I have the same thing. I think it's because, in a typical equal position after the opening, as white I think "where is my initiative, I should be able to attack here" and as black I think "well, let's see what he does, might make a mistake, I'll stay solid..."

ericmittens
Scarblac wrote:
ericmittens wrote:

Yup, Over the Board my performance rating when playing black is about 100 points higher than my actual rating. Consequently, my performance rating when playing white is about 100 points less than my actual rating!

Strange stuff, to fix this I'm drastically changing my whole white repertoire.


Is the problem with your repertoire, or your state of mind during the game?

I have the same thing. I think it's because, in a typical equal position after the opening, as white I think "where is my initiative, I should be able to attack here" and as black I think "well, let's see what he does, might make a mistake, I'll stay solid..."


There might be something to that yea...generally when I have white my state of mind is that I have the initiative and I need to keep it, but I'd say that's the correct attitude to have when playing white. No, I think that my white repertoire was a bit kiddie (I played a lot of that Tony Kosten 2.g3 english opening stuff) so now I'm playing more mainline 1.d4 openings in hopes of having an initiative I can actually use.

Golbat

I only have a Black repertoire. My White repertoire is really based off of what I've studied from the Black perspective. So I'm pretty confident in saying that I'm a stronger player with the Black pieces.

RyanMK
Total 577 (56%) 399 (38%) 63 (6%) 1039 30522
White 294 (55%) 201 (38%) 38 (7%) 533 (51%) 15452 (51%)
Black 283 (56%) 198 (39%) 25 (5%) 506 (49%) 15070 (49%)

 

Well, looks almost equal.

chesscrazy018

I have not found any difference between the two..

 

 

Got a webcam. Create a Videopoke Now!

MeteoricMike

As black I'm less likely to try fool things, like take a pawn, or advance too many pawns forward, etc. but as white I find there are more oppertunties for my opponent to screw up, as they often choose cool looking defenses they don't really understand (less so with white).

philtheforce

It all depends who I am playing. I used to love being white ... but sometimes I prefer to be black as I don't have to always dictate the moves of play? However, as I said it depends who I am playing ..... e.g. what type of player they are (aggressive, passive etc) and how strong they are. Also because I open with d4 as white i am starting to lose confidence in it as I have not been that successful with it against stronger players!

Night_Reaper

Well I have only been a member since 8 May 2009, so the number of games I've played so far is minimal - 19 games. Of these I have won 14 and playing black has given me 8 wins against 1 loss and with white 6 wins and 4 losses.

I find when playing black you are reacting to white's moves to begin with..and I have found so far that my oponents tend to play more agressively with white....and find their position tends to uravel if they aren't careful...

turn

White.

Mainline_Novelty

my records r almost identical. sorry, i cant seem to paste the thingy

Scereno

i know i prefer playing as black... but i dont know which im better at

sessmaru556

I prefer playing as white, because white always starts with a first move advantage which is crucial to me sometimes, I believe the first move advantage can sometimes be able to force a win for white.

 

Also whites winning pct decreases between Blitz games and games between Amateurs. Overall, I think playing as white is still better as you start with some advantage.

EternalChess
sessmaru556 wrote:

I prefer playing as white, because white always starts with a first move advantage which is crucial to me sometimes, I believe the first move advantage can sometimes be able to force a win for white.

 

Also whites winning pct decreases between Blitz games and games between Amateurs. Overall, I think playing as white is still better as you start with some advantage.


 agreed