Bishops vs...

Sort:
ClavierCavalier

Are there any positions that you know of where the bishop is better than the rook?

Just to clarify, positions like the one below don't really count since it's the pawn that has the power.  If one were to remove either the bishop or pawn, it'd be very different.

plutonia

it's when there aren't open files for the rooks and the bishop is controlling important squares. Typical is when the bishop is supporting an attack from the long diagonal.

Casual_Joe

Right -- when there are no open files for the Rooks, but there are open diagonals for the Bishop.

Coomberlane

Like this

Notice how the good bishop cramps his opponent's game. If white had a rook then black would have more space

plutonia

^

what are you saying, black is much better.

Open files will exist after the 2 seconds that will take for black to decide to play c6.

also, the bishop on g2 looks silly because it doesn't have targets. On top of that, it can easily be blocked and exchanged if black wanted.

 

even if it wasn't easy to open files (like it is here), a rook is still much superior to the bishop. It's only a matter of time before the rook will own the puny colorblind warrior.

bishop's chances are only related to a potential attack against the enemy king. This means: 1) targets and 2) absense of enemy's bishop to contrast it.

Nordlandia

Can i use an study as example.