I think no
Can you become a GM/IM/FM if you start as an adult?
Sort:
Most Recent
Forum Legend
Following
New Comments
Locked Topic
Pinned Topic
Hikaru claimed that the highest someone could get if they started as an adult was 1500.
I told him I thought that was too low, and he ended up replying to me (this was on reddit) doubling down, saying that in his experience he's never met someone who has done it. They always start young then get back into chess later.
I think that's nonsense, and 1500 is too low, but it's interesting how low rated players tend to think anything is possible while Hikaru is at the other extreme.
1500 OTB by the way.
I mean he mainly frequents the circle of top chess players. Those guys all started young.
It has to be a huge exaggeration.
For starters, I think Stjepan Tomic (Hanging pawns) didn't play as a kid (I am not completely sure, but I think he talked about it in some podcast. Now I might be mistaken, but I am sure there are a lot of people who started late that are significantly over 1 500 OTB.
This has to be the case especially since the chess boom in 2020. And if somehow playing chess would magically become profitable (say you are more or less guaranteed to have a certain income when you hit 2 200 OTB, better income when you hit 2 300, etc.), some people who started late would emerge. How high would they be able to get... who knows.
But as is, it is highly unlikely that such individual will emerge. Optimissed said that IM is highly unlikely as well, and he is probably correct, because apart from a great 2 400 rating, one has to have 3 great tournaments, and that requires a lot of money from some adult improver.
I don't know whether Hikaru would count me, because technically I played a few games with my dad before I was 10... but my dad didn't know all the rules, and I played fewer than 10 games before my 18th birthday, so I like to say I started as an adult.
After playing very nearly every day for 3 years (mostly trash blitz online, but I also solved puzzles and tried to learn some things) I went to my first tournament at age 21, and after a few tournaments my rating had stabilized at 1300 USCF.
I've often told the story of a retired man in his 60s who joined our chess club as a beginner. He also got to 1300 USCF, but it took him about 5 years.
So yeah... 1500 is pretty low for the absolute limit of an adult beginner.
For instance I don't count myself starting late because I learned the game at age 7-8 and played it with my friends and family from time to time. At my best, before I stopped playing it, I was probably something equivalent to 800 - 1 000 today.
Then 2020. happened and I got back to it, I was 1 200 inside 2 weeks of playing with the help of some basic videos and whatnot.
But you, I think you are as close to an adult improver (who basically started in adulthood) as it gets. Maybe moving the pieces around as a kid helped you slightly (to me a little bit more, I admit I had some of the basics down), but I don't think it is impactful enough in your case to not be a proof that you can get a lot higher than 1 500 if you start late.