Heck, I think they're sort of funny.
Chess.com implementing the "like/dislike button"?


I saw sometime ago, where there used to be a browser addon, this allowed you to annotate web pages, and only people with the addon would see these annotations.
Maybe we could have something like that. That way it doesn't affect anything on the actual web pages, and we can, for our benefit simply, click on a post or thread as spam, and on our own browser it won't be any longer visible. However, ther real pages won't be in anyway affected.
This can be extended, by simply having an option in the app-addon with say,'what others are saying'. Just to see, well, other peoples vote. So if someone votes up a troll post, it wouldn't matter, because we can simply look and mark it spam, and we no longer see it. Everything happens on the client side.
This can be extended to 'people we want to read', and 'people we don't want to read'.
So if we see someone all the time just posting spam, we can, on our side hide their posts. Again, they won't know, nor would anybody else.
Because the problem that has been pointed out is that a good post can be disliked, and a trash post can be liked. By not marking the actual pages, this behavior is prevented.
We know what we like, we just mark it, like. And we just might do something like share statistics with friend. So people whose opinion we value, we can see what they are reading, and they can see ours.
But the basic idea is that it won't give the trolls any further attention.

And also, instead of tallying up likes and dislikes, it should follow the formula g=x-y
g = how good a thread supposedly is based on people's opinions
x = number of likes
y = number of dislikes

The biggest problem with facebook is that there is no dislike button to balance things out. Absolute crap content still only has likes which badly skews the REAL value of the content. I'd hate to see that happen here.
Interesting point. And lets not leave out the Meh button.

there should be a rating on each thread ( 1-5) to see how good the thread is so more people can be interested in it
also a karma system, sort of like rep power should be installed. bad posters get negged, and good posters get repped.
Anything like this is better than what is currently here.

And then we doubtless get to see a whole bunch of lame threads getting lauded to the skies. Yeah, good plan.

Gross. Imagine the Parham trolls (from days of yore) pumping up their threads' ratings as really positive, while bashing everyone else's threads.

Gross. Imagine the Parham trolls (from days of yore) pumping up their threads' ratings as really positive, while bashing everyone else's threads.
that will keep you busy.

This could be an excellent idea just for tactics trainer, for the comments on the tactics.
-1 for anyone who posts how easy the tactic is, and how awesome he is for posting his 100% score in big red letters. They can continue to boast if they feel good about it, and we can vote them down and hopefully make them hidden.
This could make it easier to have good discussions relevant to the tactic. Everytime I get a notification for new comments on a tactic I'm following, there is a 50% It's just a new score poster.
Wow, who would've expected that sort of thing from Elubas?