The fear was in him. He said that if he played Karpov, he was going to insist on a long match. After not playing for three years, he was very concerned about how good he would be.
Fischer was afraid of Karpov?

In 1975, my money would have been on Fischer. He was the better player and his form would have returned. Fischer's rating in 1992 was 2660 - only 125 below his peak 20 years earlier - so he would have surely been the strongest player in the world in 1975, and would have been competitive with the 2 K's even in 1982.
To explain the last point, it is likely the amount of strength lost in 1972 to 1982 would be less than half that from 1972 to 1992 - typically the fall in rating accelerates.
@63
Around 1982 both Karpov and Kasparov would have been stronger than Fischer.
The approximate strength of Fischer is above that of Spassky, who was still active.
http://www.chessmetrics.com/cm/CM2/PlayerProfile.asp?Params=199510SSSSS3S062745000000111000000000000010100