I'm John Musacha. Ask me anything.

Sort:
Kronsteeen

Will flight 370 be found? If so when and where?

sapientdust
zborg wrote:

Whose buried in Grant's tomb ?

Whose WHAT is buried in Grant's tomb?

sapientdust

Question for Musacha: why is there something rather than nothing?

Iluvsmetuna

Because of thinking, formerly known as the thing king, right Johnny ?

Iluvsmetuna

is the Bermuda triangle isosceles, scalene or equilateral ?

josiah777

Scalene

macer75
sapientdust wrote:

Question for Musacha: why is there something rather than nothing?

How do you know there is something rather than nothing?

Iluvsmetuna

man!!! thats deep!

RonaldJosephCote

               Macer;  nothing would leave a trace that something WAS there!Undecided

macer75
RonaldJosephCote wrote:

               Macer;  nothing would leave a trace that something WAS there!

I dunno... that doesn't spund like a great explanation. But at least it's better than nothing. Tongue Out

Iluvsmetuna

i prefer nothing

macer75

Nah, just AFK.

RonaldJosephCote

           MU  (as in music, or cows)  Sasha as in the actress Isles, of "Rizzoli & Isles.   When your drunk, its music with a cha cha tacked on.  OH, I see my keyboard isn't working right.  Ok, in the shop it goessss.

sapientdust
macer75 wrote:
sapientdust wrote:

Question for Musacha: why is there something rather than nothing?

How do you know there is something rather than nothing?

Something has the experience of seeming to exist -- namely, the barely sapient agglomeration of stardust that seems to be typing these very words and that goes by the username sapientdust.

Even if the experience is deceptive or the perception erroneous, some kind of system exists in order to support the experience, regardless of the actual nature of the experience.

Descartes got many things wrong, but on this, he was correct.

Iluvsmetuna

still it all seems to amount to nothing in the end

Iluvsmetuna

easy! just put the peaces together.

which is a lot less intellectual than wondering if the human race as a collective can reach the level of intelligence needed to end global conflict.

maybe just an old pray to the god of peace might work ? worth a try ?

macer75
sapientdust wrote:
macer75 wrote:
sapientdust wrote:

Question for Musacha: why is there something rather than nothing?

How do you know there is something rather than nothing?

Something has the experience of seeming to exist -- namely, the barely sapient agglomeration of stardust that seems to be typing these very words and that goes by the username sapientdust.

Even if the experience is deceptive or the perception erroneous, some kind of system exists in order to support the experience, regardless of the actual nature of the experience.

Descartes got many things wrong, but on this, he was correct.

What if the concept of existence in itself doesn't really "exist" - it's simply an illusion, not real in a way that the human mind is not capable of understanding? That is to say, the distinction between so called existence and so called non-existence is merely artificial?

I know I'm not making myself clear here, and I myself am not 100% sure what I want to say here. I guess the bottom line of my argument is that it's possible that there are things out minds just aren't capable of understanding, that our understanding of logic, while it may seem to hold universal truth (by definition of the concept of logic itself), cannot explain because it is actually limited or erroneous?

sapientdust

If "it's simply an illusion", then something exists (illusions, for example), but I think I get what you're saying. I kind of agree if you meant that the question may be a category mistake of some kind (or some other similar error). Just as Chomsky's famous nonsensical sentence "colorless green ideas sleep furiously" doesn't have any meaning, the question about existence may have no answer because it misuses concepts or language in some way. Or it may be a meaningful question, but there is no reason why, as is apparently the case for some quantum events.

Anyway, I'm off to read Nothingness.

Iluvsmetuna

wont do you any good

johnmusacha

-25