One Queen or Two Rooks?

Sort:
Avatar of FlyingPotato131


     Imagine you are starting a game where both players get a single king, but your only additional pieces can be either one queen or two rooks. What would you choose? Your opponent gets whatever you don’t choose.

Avatar of UltimateCreatorofBob

Two rooks, because you can lose one and still be able to checkmate.

Avatar of JLthegreat
Queen because it can easily fork the king and one of The rooks
Avatar of UltimateCreatorofBob

True.

Avatar of JLthegreat
[Site "Chess.com iPhone"]
[Date "12/17/2019 08:06PM"]
[FEN "r3k2r/pppppppp/8/8/8/8/PPPPPPPP/3QK3 w kq - 0 0"]
[White "Computer (Level 20) (0)"]
[Black "Computer (Level 20) (0)"]

1.d4 O-O 2.Qd3 b6 3.g4 e6 4.g5 d5 5.b4 c5 6.dxc5 bxc5 7.bxc5 Rfc8 8.Qa3 Rc7 9.f3 Rac8 10.Kf2 Rxc5 11.Qxa7 Rxc2 12.h4 g6 13.a4 Rd8 14.a5 Rcc8 15.Qe7 Re8 16.Qd7 Rcd8 17.Qc6 Rc8 18.Qb7 Rb8 19.Qd7 Rbd8 20.Qc6 Rc8 21.Qb7 Rb8 22.Qd7 Red8 23.Qe7 Re8 24.Qd7
Avatar of JLthegreat
Game was drawn by the two computers
Avatar of UltimateCreatorofBob

What for?

Avatar of UltimateCreatorofBob

Oh. me slow typer.

Avatar of JLthegreat
Game with 2 rooks vs a queen
Avatar of JLthegreat
Every piece was in its original position
Avatar of WindowsEnthusiast

Two rooks are generally a little better than a queen, especially in the presence of pawns.

Avatar of FlyingPotato131

I thought a queen was better, it has more freedom and can threaten a rook and a king

Avatar of FlyingPotato131

But I felt like getting some other opinions

Avatar of UltimateCreatorofBob

In my opinion, I want both options.

Avatar of FlyingPotato131

Don’t we all 😜😭😩

Avatar of cman8

Rh1+

Rook wins with skewer

Avatar of FlyingPotato131

White goes first, not black. Therefore that skewer can be avoided.

Avatar of KingSideInvasion

The general rule is that it depends on king safety. If you have good king safety and the rooks can coordinate well then two rooks. If your king safety is poor you are almost always worse with two rooks because the queen will harass the king and often win one of the rooks.

Avatar of Malishious

I'd say two Rooks guarantees at the very least a draw with perfect play, and since you can win with just one, I'd say that two pieces are better than one

Avatar of Guest5702354923
Please Sign Up to comment.

If you need help, please contact our Help and Support team.