Please estimate the ratings of these players

Sort:
S_Moufid

Hello guys, i have a game here that i would for you to take a quick look at it, and estimate the ELO rating of each player.

you can give your own estimation, just take a look at the moves and tell me how much is white rated, and how much is black rated.



please specify the ratings like this for example:

White: x
Black: y

thank you so much in advance.

PS: you are free to give any ratings, it all depends on what you think of the game.

KirbyCake

white 800

black 1400

Comrade_Jackal

White: 1500

Black: 1750

KirbyCake
Ed_Seedhouse wrote:

Oh I think that an 800 player would make lots more bad blunders than white did here - really only one total clanger.  I'd guess White was at least 1400 and black maybe 1600-1800.

But even Grandmasters make blunders like this on rare occasions.

white is making moves like e3 c3 dxe5? almost every beginner knows those are bad opening moves.

 

the only people who play openings like that are real beginners with 0 training.

IMpatzer

W 1250 b 1400

takeoffeh

You would have to know the time control to get a better idea, but black seems to clearly be the better player. The first estimate of 1600 for black is way too high. A 1600 player would have played more sharply. The lines chosen by this player are very drawish and not suited to a match with such a weak player. In fact, black only gained any sort of advantage when white blundered a pawn. My estimate is W:1000, B: 1300

Nekhemevich

w: 1200 b: 2000+

S_Moufid

Thanks guys, by averaging the scores you suggested, i think its safe to say that :

 

White's ELO performance is about : ~1200

Black's ELO performance is about : ~1580

amerxp00

I think that:

White's ELO performance is about : ~1200

and 

Black's ELO performance is about : ~1580

MuhammadAreez10

White 1050, Black 1400.