You have answered your own question nicely, isthatso. Plus the other inputs, we get a clearer picture of why non-titled players have higher ratings than titled players here.
However it's disturbing to see people readily jumping to the conclusion that just because a non-titled player is higher-rated than titled players, he/she must be cheating. Such blanket accusations are unjust.
The truth is that titled players don't play that many games as non-titled players. They don't have as much time to spare on online games due to OTB commitments. And the games they do play online seem to be selective games, mostly coaching games for their students.
The non-titled players on the other hand have no such constraints. They play as much as they like, take part in as many team matches and tournaments as they wish. So of course they are piling up rating points, unlike the titled players who play far fewer games and therefore not earning as many points. At some point in time, their rating points will overtake and surpass that of titled players.
you seem one of those very few honest guys prawn. Tellme this, if you not mind:) Currently I am at TT puzzle's strength of round about 1550. What I want to know is where does these ratings stop, do you get puzzles that would be at 2300 strength, for example. /or do they give combinations of simpler puzzles that need more moves to solve? I never redo puzzles that I missed the first time, but what I find is that the harder they get, the simpler they feel to solve. the lower rated puzzles felt harder to solve, why is that?
chess engines will give the shortest lines to mate, but for humans, we use longer and weirder way's to loose rather to win. anyhow, there are some pretty good players that can win chess engines, and allow the engine to function without pulling the plug and switching it off.
creativity is what would win an engine, i am sure that when you go with a line that is creative enough, one can change the outcome, or be creative and challenge the engine with another engine of equal strength, and that woul leave your creativity unchallenged:D