Chess - Play & Learn


FREE - In Google Play

FREE - in Win Phone Store


Software detailing WHY a move is better

  • #1

    Hi there!

    I've already gone through the forum and know about the usual gang of softwares: Fritz, Chessbase, Hiarcs, CM etc

    What I was looking for is, perhaps, niche: I was looking for a software, preferably Mac (Intel), that explains, as a human coach would, the blunders made and the better variations available. I understand that engines tell you that a move is better but they do not tell me WHY it is better.

    Has such a software been made? Thanks for your input! :-)

  • #2

    I don't know about software, but Chess Mentor here is pretty good - you get it as part of diamond membership and it is very helpful.

  • #3

    Thank you but Chess mentor is still only a series of lessons

  • #4

    Not only has such a software not been made, it cannot be made with current engines.  Heuristics were long ago abandoned for brute force type searches.  The computers don't know "why" they choose moves either, so it's rather impossible to write software explaining these moves as a human would explain them.

    This is why human coaches are better heh (and why programs range from unhelpful to detrimental to new players).  Chess mentor is as close as it gets because a human master wrote explanations for why all legal moves are wrong or right for every step of each lesson.

    Anyway if you don't/can't get a coach you can always post your games in the analysis section of this site (for free of course) and get human answers for why certain moves are good or not.  (You can even ask specifically why ____ was better on move #____).

  • #5

    The forum or online videos are the best ''software.''

  • #6

    ok thanks for the input guys!

  • #7
    ahmedjhang wrote:

    Thank you but Chess mentor is still only a series of lessons

    I gather you've used Chess Mentor for several hours or more and know a lot about it? I've taken 118 lessons in it so far (a tiny fraction of what's available) and have done many of them twice in order to reinforce important points I missed the first time. But then again I'm only rated 2151 (online chess) so what do I know?

    For starters cut back on blitz games if you want to improve and try playing a few online games to get experience in analyzing more deeply than is possible OTB  

    How else do you think most people learn other than by taking lessons? You're living in some sort of dreamworld if you expect engines no matter how powerful to actually be anywhere near as good much less better than reading a good chess book, going thru the chess mentor and tactics trainer and playing of course as well as getting tips and advice from stronger players if possible - I don't think you need to pay a coach unless you're really rolling in dough.

    There's also thousands of good articles here written by masters if you start looking at what's available you shouldn't have any trouble finding plenty of articles on whatever you're interested in - any phase of the game among other topics. There's also thousands of blogs here as well and some of them are worth reading 

    I hope I haven't rained on your parade too hard and you'll consider reading a chess book along with a few articles and blogs now and then instead of solely relying on software to learn from. 



  • #8

    Its not quite fair to say that computers don't know why one move is better than another, although their evaluation function is simply a number, that number represents a material or positional imbalance in favour of one side or the other. For example a pawn move that creates an expoitable outpost for an opponent might show up as -0.5 in the game analysis and there might be an informator 'better is' symbol next to an alternative move in the notes that avoids creating that hole.

    Of course, you still have to interpret those things yourself but thats part of getting better at the game.

  • #9

    Such "software" does exist. It's called brains.

    Everybody has it. It's free. You just need to use that software properly.

    A computer can learn you a lot of things- but definitely not how to use your brains to good effect.

    A computer cannot teach you how to use them, quite simply because computers can't give advices about something they don't have, or understand.

    While a good coach will undoubtedly help you optimize your software's performance, that fact alone will not improve your chess at all. OK, now you do know how to use your brains, but it doesn't suffice: You must convert your new skills to something, and that can be achieved only by dedicated, hard work- no more, and no less than that.


Online Now