Is 'The Art of Chess Attack' by Vukovic outdated?

Sort:
Avatar of Franci77

I'm 1800 OTB FIDE. I played a lot when I was younger and just returned last January. 

Read back 'My system', 'How to reassess your chess', and 'Endgame course' by Silman. I was thinking about reading the art of chess attack but they now told me that is outdated. What do you think? Any other books that you suggest?

Avatar of justbefair

Who is "they", as in "they told me"?

A lot of people have expressed a good opinion of the book.

https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess-equipment/the-art-of-attack-for-early-intermediate-players

Avatar of marqumax
A lot of mistakes in that book. I found it fun to refute some of the lines
Avatar of justbefair
marqumax wrote:
A lot of mistakes in that book. I found it fun to refute some of the lines

Well, John Nunn issued a new edition in 1999 in algebraic and with corrections and notes.

Were you using his edition?

Avatar of blueemu

Some of the specific variations are wrong.

The concepts that the book teaches are timeless.


Best chess book ever written: Pawn Power in Chess by Hans Kmoch.

It must have added 500 points to my playing strength. Eventually. When I got the point.

You'll need to learn a new terminology and then read the book two or three times, though.

Avatar of Jenium

It's a great read. It contains a lot of classical attacking games. Personally I don't care if the given lines contain holes. After all I am not reading a chess book in the hopes to get exactly the same position or to find the truth of a position.

Avatar of marqumax
I think it’s good for books to have mistakes in variations. It keeps you sharp
Avatar of Soumya765p

It's great

Avatar of Mazetoskylo

No, it is not.

Tactical mistakes in the analysis? Sure enough, I can barely find books without such mistakes -including Kasparov's My Great Predecessors where (outdated) engines were used in the analytical procedure.

Overall books like this one, or Shereshevsky's Endgame Stategy are terrific, and tactical omissions aren't really important. You will play against a human, not a modern machine, after all.