Was Alekhine assassinated?

Sort:
ArchbishopCheckmate

Grandmaster Larry Evans had first-hand contact with the actual medical examiner who attended Alekkine's body in 1946. He wrote to Evans while he had a column with Chess Life.  This was way before I was even board. The article of Evans pretty much assured everyone Alekhine died of asphyxiation from choking on a piece of steak while dining alone.

gargraves
ArchbishopCheckmate wrote:

Grandmaster Larry Evans had first-hand contact with the actual medical examiner who attended Alekkine's body in 1946. He wrote to Evans while he had a column with Chess Life.  This was way before I was even board. The article of Evans pretty much assured everyone Alekhine died of asphyxiation from choking on a piece of steak while dining alone.

Similar is found hereBill Wall

JessieWong

Conspiracy????

gargraves
JessieWong wrote:

Conspiracy????

I doubt it. A drunk old guy, alone, eating steak, it is plausible that he choked on meat,or had a heart attack, and, they did find meat blocking his windpipe. The tales of the Soviets fearing his chess domination in a comeback are exaggerated a bit- it makes for a good story, and helps elevate his memory as a chess master so feared that they had one logical option- send a killer a thousand miles to a small town and kill him, make it look accidental.

JamieDelarosa
gargraves wrote:
JessieWong wrote:

Conspiracy????

I doubt it. A drunk old guy, alone, eating steak, it is plausible that he choked on meat,or had a heart attack, and, they did find meat blocking his windpipe. The tales of the Soviets fearing his chess domination in a comeback are exaggerated a bit- it makes for a good story, and helps elevate his memory as a chess master so feared that they had one logical option- send a killer a thousand miles to a small town and kill him, make it look accidental.

You don't think the (in)famous death photos were staged?  See Post#2

If they were, what else was staged?

I'll bet you have never heard of the NKVD.  The Soviets had agents stationed in Portugal.

aflfooty

Alekhine played in the famous "unfinished tournament" in manheim germany in 1914. A truly remarkable story

Sachman1978

It's an interesting conspiracy but I don't think the Soviets would have gone to the trouble of killing Alekhine, Stalin had bigger fish to fry in 1946.

The photos were staged but it was done for profit not politics.  The photographer probably just placed Alekhine's body and the chessboard in those positions for a better picture.

 Did you see the state of Alekhine in the years before he died?  He looked in his 70s but was just past 50.  He was over the hill, an alcoholic and dying from kidney failure.

varelse1

Jamie

What in that photo says "staged" to you?

varelse1
Sachan_1978 wrote:

It's an interesting conspiracy but I don't think the Soviets would have gone to the trouble of killing Alekhine, Stalin had bigger fish to fry in 1946.

The photos were staged but it was done for profit not politics.  The photographer probably just placed Alekhine's body and the chessboard in those positions for a better picture.

 Did you see the state of Alekhine in the years before he died?  He looked in his 70s but was just past 50.  He was over the hill, an alcoholic and dying from kidney failure.

If it was an assassination, ( which I am not saying it was) I would be more inclined to believe French Nazi hunters were the culprits.

thenextlevelpro

suspicious

navinashok

He quit smoking in 1936

JamieDelarosa
varelse1 wrote:

Jamie

What in that photo says "staged" to you?

Would a person choking to death serenely sit in front of a set up chessboard and empty dishes?  There were multiple picture of the scene taken by the same photographer, with subtle differences.  Clearly a case of manipulation of the setting.

varelse1
JamieDelarosa wrote:
varelse1 wrote:

Jamie

What in that photo says "staged" to you?

Would a person choking to death serenely sit in front of a set up chessboard and empty dishes?  There were multiple picture of the scene taken by the same photographer, with sublte differences.  Clearly a case of manipulation of the setting.

I don't know much about choking deaths,other than what I seen on TV.

I suppose there is a certain logic to that.

Vlandian_Knight
enotSgnilloR wrote:

Yes, def murdered.  Also, a few of the recent GM deaths in Russia have been murders as well.  When the Russian Federation reports a death from natural causes, don't believe it.  Too coincidental so many of these guys "jumped" to their death.

Probably assassinated, and it wouldn't be the first time. At least we have his books, theory, and games (but somewhat surprised they weren't scrubbed from history).

JamieDelarosa

The machinations of the old Soviet Union went far beyond what history records.

mpaetz

     Any death not caused by violent trauma is technically said to be caused  by heart failure. What causes the heart to fail may be lack of oxygen to the brain, shutting down the autonomic nervous system that controls the heart, loss of blood causing the heart to "seize up", or a hundred other things. A drunken, terminally ill old man may have passed out while eating, or started to choke and suffered s heart attack, or suffered heart failure while eating, leaving a piece of meat stuck in his throat.

     All these conspiracy theories are amusing. French revenge? He wasn't French and didn't participate in any Nazi activities in France. Stalin's revenge for fleeing Russia and denouncing Bolshevism? He would have been killed 10 years earlier in that case. Perhaps it was death rays from Venus. The best evidence comes from the most prominent pathologist in Portugal at the time, who performed the autopsy and declared that the proximate cause of death was choking on a chunk of meat.

JamieDelarosa

Could have been the Soviet NKVD (forerunners of the KGB), could have been the French, as payback.

Alekhine was widely viewed as Nazi collaborator and stooge

AunTheKnight

I'd hope he wasn't!

tygxc

As always for such questions Winter is the authority

https://www.chesshistory.com/winter/extra/alekhine3.html#:~:text=The%20autopsy%20revealed%20that%20Alekhine's,place%2C%20neither%20suicide%20nor%20homicide.

 

JamieDelarosa

I did not see whether Winter came to a conclusion.  But he does point out the death scene was compromised.