Was Alekhine assassinated?

Sort:
enotSgnilloR

Yes, def murdered.  Also, a few of the recent GM deaths in Russia have been murders as well.  When the Russian Federation reports a death from natural causes, don't believe it.  Too coincidental so many of these guys "jumped" to their death.

JamieDelarosa

A "witness" to the death scene was Luis Lupi, who took the black and white photos.  He wrote on 24 March 1946 to Robert Bunnell, of the Associated Press in London, the following description:

‘Dear Bunnelle,

 

Herewith please find four (4) negatives and three prints of EXCLUSIVE ASSOCIATED PRESS PHOTOS taken by me. They are ALEXANDER ALEKHINE last photographs. I took these pixs with a small camera that I borrowed in the Hotel Park in Estoril where I rushed to cover the Alekhine death story – without my own camera! This is why they are not so good.
Pixs show ALEKHINE lying dead in his hotel room just as he was found in the morning of 24/3, by one hotel waiter. He must have died the night before (23/3) at about eleven p.m. as, according to the porter of the hotel, the Chess Champion went in about 23.40 – and had ordered his dinner to his room as usual.

 

He seemed to be sleeping so calm and natural he looked. Doctors said he must have died suddenly just when he was beginning to eat. On his right hand he still held a beefsteak – He ate with his hands and used knife and fork only when he ate in public…
The giant of Chess – dead, resembled a fallen oak tree. In his face he kept an expression of deep thought.
For captions suggest you use (if you will use these gruesome pixs…) and rewrite my messages of 23/3 slugged 01230 and 02345. Will you have a couple of prints on these negatives (a couple of each, please)? and oblige

 

Yours sincerely, Luís C Lupi.’


24 March was the same day that Alekhine's corpse was discovered in the hotel room at about 11 AM.  Lupi had to have had the film developed immediately that day (a Sunday?).
 
As Lupi wrote, he took multiple photographs.  Here is another one, taken from a slightly different angle.
 
Note the subtle difference in the scene from the previous photo, on Page 1.  In the upper right corner of each photo, there are two vases. Next to the vases are a black binder, in one picture with some light-colored papers on top of it.
 
Other sources say that Lupi had placed the chessboard adjacent to the dining table for sensationalistic effect.  In either case, the "official photos" of the death scene suggest manipulation.
 
 
JamieDelarosa

Here is the link to Edward Winter's article, "Alekhine's Death":

http://www.chesshistory.com/winter/extra/alekhine3.html

enotSgnilloR

Anyone who has ever murdered and staged the ensuing photograph knows this was def staged.

Steve11537

Hm, a piece of meat three inches long blocking his windpipe and it was "unchewed" ?

 

If he really was choking to death, I don't theink he would have leaned back in his chair. He would have jumped up, bend over forward trying to dislodge the meat from his throat.

 

As with the other inconsistencies on the photo, somethting definately is fishy there.

JamieDelarosa

BTW, some of the best information published regarding the circumstances of Alekhine's last days came from Portuguese chess champion, Francisco Lupi, the son of Luis Lupi.

Francisco was a friend and confidante of Alekhine during the last few months of the Champion's life.

From Francisco we get details of the autopsy.

SaintGermain32105

He probably just died of pneumonia and starvation but it was too big of an insult for the chess world.

JamieDelarosa

Why was Luis Lupi at Alekhine's hotel room?   He states the body was found about 11:00 AM by a hotel worker.

We have a problem with the time line though.

Francisco Lupi wrote:

‘The autopsy said of him that he suffered from arterio-sclerosis, chronic gastritis and duodenitis, that his heart weighed 350 grammes, that the perimeter of his skull was 540 millimeters, and so on …

All I know is that on Sunday morning about 10.30 I was awakened and asked to hurry to Estoril, because something had happened to “old Dr Alex”. I entered his room together with the Portuguese authorities. There he was, sitting in his chair, in so calm an attitude that one would have thought that he was asleep. There was only a little foam at the corner of his mouth.'

SaintGermain32105

What would cause him to foam at the mouth? 
Google search of people having heart attacks foaming at the mouth. 

JamieDelarosa

Who was Luis Lupi, anyway?  According to Spraggett:

Luis C. Lupi [was] the government-appointed representative of Associated Press in Portugal, a high ranking PIDE official, and step-father of Francesco Lupi.

What was the PIDE?  The acronym stands for Polícia Internacional e de Defesa do Estado.  They were the state security service, or secret police, in the regime of the Portuguese dictator, Antonio Salazar.

Hmmmm.  If it was Luis who called Francisco at about 10:30 AM, he must have been in Alekhine's room before the body was supposedly discovered at 11:00.  Why were the state police there, as compared to the local authorities?  Why was the death scene tampered with (as seen in the photos)?  Was the official account of death by choking on a piece of meat a concocted cover story?

TheOldReb

I think few people actually believe the official story that Alekhine choked to death on a piece of meat so the question becomes who was responsible for his murder and why would Portuguese authorities go along with the cover up ? 

JamieDelarosa

As I recall, Reb, you lived in Portugal at one time.  Am I mistaken?

TheOldReb

Yes Jamie , I did live in Lisbon for 14 years . I am now back in the USA . 

enotSgnilloR

AutisticCath

I question the theory of choking as well. It seems poor Alekhine had a case of SADS (sudden adult death syndrome) which very often occurs when one dozes off (from food coma in the case of Alekhine). Why would he always be mucking around with a chess board? Perhaps he wanted it set up for decoration.

I frankly don't buy into these conspiracy theories so unless you can present me with evidence from a non-conspiracy source that says he was assassinated or possibly assassinated, your argument that he was assassinated is as good as those 9/11 Truthers' arguments.

JamieDelarosa
newengland7 wrote:

I question the theory of choking as well. It seems poor Alekhine had a case of SADS (sudden adult death syndrome) which very often occurs when one dozes off (from food coma in the case of Alekhine). Why would he always be mucking around with a chess board? Perhaps he wanted it set up for decoration.

I frankly don't buy into these conspiracy theories so unless you can present me with evidence from a non-conspiracy source that says he was assassinated or possibly assassinated, your argument that he was assassinated is as good as those 9/11 Truthers' arguments.

You missed the Sherlock Holmes quotation earlier, didnt you?

The "official" "non-conspiracy" source is full of inconsistencies.  No, worse than that - it is fatally flawed.

Robert_New_Alekhine

I am not dead, nor was I assasinated! Stop spreading lies!

AutisticCath

Well like I said, get me the peer-reviewed work which says he was assassinated and I'll believe it. Judging on the man's alocohol intake, the cause of death was very likely highly uninteresting.

Kretinovich

Anyone wanna play an alekhine thematic tournament?

RookSacrifice_OLD
Robert_New_Alekhine wrote:

I am not dead, nor was I assasinated! Stop spreading lies!

No one said you were dead. Undecided