What is better : bishop or knight ?

Sort:
Avatar of VenemousViper

I was wondering is it good to exchange a bishop for a knight? Does it depend on you level, also?

Avatar of chessterd5

It depends on the position. The general view is that knights are better in closed positions. Bishops are better in open positions.

Avatar of VenemousViper
chessterd5 wrote:

It depends on the position. The general view is that knights are better in closed positions. Bishops are better in open positions.

I know that but what about in openings like the Ruy Lopez?

Avatar of long_quach

Knights are better because they are less powerful.

Think about that for a moment.

Bishops are predictable.

Knights are fancy dancers with fancy footwork. It changes color with every move. That's the key to chess. To be versatile and agile.

Avatar of long_quach

I think I read this in The Book of Five Rings - Miyamoto Musashi.

A person who wields a bow is called a bowman.

A person who wields a spear is called a spearman.

A person who wields a sword is called a strategist.

Bow and arrows are linear, predictable.

A spear is "straightforward" by definition. A spear is a powerful weapon.

But a sword is as agile as the human hand. You don't know which direction it will come at you.

That is why a swordsman is called a strategist.

Avatar of Aeacb_7221
ur mom
Avatar of LOUD

Bishop imo

Avatar of Kyobir

THE KNIIIIIIIIIGHT

Avatar of Pegusu

Definitely the knight, because he can make the one move that the queen can’t make.

Avatar of NotAUniqueUserName

A person who wields a "long knife" is a strategist. In bronze-age languages, sword must be two-edged, so they use knife for "one-edged sword". In medieval-age languages, a sword has a pommel act as a nut and the end of the tang as a bolt; a knife has its handle riveted to the tang. A Japanese sword is a German knife.

Avatar of sb3turbo

assuming that you are not a master at tactics (since you are asking this) you just need to know basic principles of material values.

  • they are both 3 points of value
  • bishops are considered to be more powerful in open positions, mostly in endgames.
  • knights are considered to be more powerful in closed positions.. like in the opening phases. that's why you are advised to develop your knights before your bishops.. 
  • bishops and rooks are more powerful when you have them as pairs. knight pairs are good at protecting eachother.
  • knights are also good blockaders of passed pawns since they can block a pawn and attack one of its defenders (another pawn usually)

thats all there is to it. now you have the wisdom, go and spead the word loL

Avatar of Gambitiodic

It is largely positional and conditional on the stage of the game. A bishop loses value when your pawns are locked into chains on its own color; is smothered or inactive. I find a bishop is most powerful late in the opening and middle game when long diagonals appear.

In the endgame, I would almost always prefer a knight do to its ability to threaten any square on the board with enough moves. A bishop, although it can threaten more squares at once, can only threaten half the squares.

I would also say that knights inflate in value against less experienced opponents. Forks threats don't occur on a predictable, diagonal line and can therefore be difficult to perceive. Playing against a novice, your knight can very often trade against a major piece in devious fork attack.

Avatar of UpcommingGM

It depends on the position. But knight and bishop are roughly equal.

Avatar of cubing1pro

knights are hard to take but bishops can take pieces with lots of mobility

Avatar of 123abc456def678j

In space the Bishop is better as it covers more space, however the knight is better in situations where there are notar

Avatar of Turtley78

Knight

Avatar of 123abc456def678j

*not as many open spaces

Avatar of innerdarkness23

innerdarkness23

Avatar of thedoggo3737

I think the knight is just better overall

Avatar of calbitt5750
When there are lots of pieces on the board knights are more powerful because they can jump so always cover 8 squares and bishops don’t have open diagonals yet. When the board clears, bishops come into their own, with open diagonals covering up to 14 squares and corner to corner range.