because they don't know the opera house game
Why do so many people play 3...Bg4 in the Philidor when everybody knows it's bad

Excuse me, what was the first game you ever saw in you life?
That game.
Same answer from the who;e chess community.

actually i understand it can be ok if and only if black is willing to gambit a pawn
Are you talking about this horrible line, by any chance?

Typically the people playing Bg4 don't have any tricky continuation in their mind either, that's why it sucks so badly. As Fiveofswords, I believe Bg4 can be played, if you are willing to give up something for some activity

It's interesting when a person like pfren deltes a comment.
Maybe he posted White's effective counter to the ..Nd7 gambit, but he took it away because he didn't want to reward you for spamming the thread!!!!
Even high-rated players do it! Why?????