Yet Another World Championship Proposal

Sort:
kco

I don't think there is too much of a problem with the WCC, problem probably lie in the candidate for the challenger. A good example would be in the Anand - Gelfard.  

sapientdust
kco wrote:

I don't think there is too much of a problem with the WCC, problem probably lie in the candidate for the challenger. A good example would be in the Anand - Gelfard.  

The problem with the WCC currently is that deciding the champion based on who wins a rapid game or a blitz armageddon game is ludicrous. It has very little to do with determining who is the best match player at standard time controls, which is what it's supposed to be all about.

The other problem is that in cases where the stronger rapid/blitz player is weaker at standard time controls, the rational strategy for them is to try to force a draw through any means necessary in every game and save the fight for the rapid/blitz play -- the Grischuk strategy, which is contrary to the spirit of the WC.

Another problem is that when you have two players (like Gelfand and Anand) who are no longer at the very top of the world, the next match will only have 1 new player in it, as we saw here. It would have been better if after neither Anand nor Gelfand proved really deserving of the title in 2012, the top two finishers in the 2013 qualifers would have played for the title, and we could have had a Carlsen-Kramnik match, and all the discussion about whether Carlsen beating Anand really means anything since Kramnik is who he really needs to beat would be redundant. Instead, we'll have to wait until perhaps 2014.

kco

I don't like the rapid/blitz either to determine the winner after the standard time control still come to a draw. Luckily we didn't see that in the Anand - Carlsen match. 

AndyClifton
sapientdust wrote:

Is there satire that you really love?

Alice in Wonderland (and the sequel)...just about my favorite book(s) ever.  Also Roald Dahl and John Collier...stuff like that. Smile  Ah yes, and the Cautionary Verses of Hillaire Belloc:  an absolute hoot.

sapientdust

I really like Alice... and the sequel too. Have you seen Gardner's The Annotated Alice?

Hadn't heard of Belloc or Cautionary Verses, but it looks dark and hilarious -- thanks for the recommendation.

kco

I am still sticking with the Grand Slam idea. Smile

AndyClifton

Edward Gorey can also be a lot of fun (although it is rather hit and miss, for me at least)...sort of an even kookier version of Chas Addams.