Text and images removed by moderators, with no reason given.

Sort:
vickalan

In one of our threads for setting up games (like here), I posted some text with an image such as this:

null

The text and image were removed by a moderator, with no reason given.

Is this because there might have been a copyright concern?

Or is this considered too graphic for chess.com?

In the case of a copyright concern, this image is from England's Grievance Discovered in Relation to the Coal Trade, 1655, and is in the public domain because its copyright has expired. But I understand moderators don't have to check this type of stuff. If I posted the image showing the copyright has expired, could the image have remained?

Lagomorph

Forget about copyright.

 

This is their forum, their rules. If they think your picture was questionable (in what context is women being hanged relevant to chess ?) it will be removed.

 

If you dont like it you know where the door is

vickalan

The picture is a reference to witches being hanged - we are playing "Bulldog chess with witch".

I was looking for some plausible explanation for why the image was removed. That's all. It's not a bid deal. I have no plans to stop playing chess at chess.com.

Lagomorph
vickalan wrote:

 we are playing "Bulldog chess with witch".

 

 

Of course you were, it all makes perfect sense now.

 

notmtwain
vickalan wrote:

The picture is a reference to witches being hanged - we are playing "Bulldog chess with witch".

I was looking for some plausible explanation for why the image was removed. That's all. It's not a bid deal. I have no plans to stop playing chess at chess.com.

Now that you know, you should remove it quickly.

Reposting items that have been removed is a really asking for it.

vickalan
Lagomorph wrote:
vickalan wrote:

 we are playing "Bulldog chess with witch". 

Of course you were, it all makes perfect sense now

 

how come nobody believes me whenever I say that?meh.png

vickalan
notmtwain wrote:

 

Reposting items that have been removed is a really asking for it.

 

Will I get hanged too?shock.png

SuperSam1

Lol. They wouldn't mute or ban vickalan. He's too valuable a member. He pretty much runs the variants section of the forums.

SuperSam1

 Did they fix the problem or did you just repost it?

vickalan

I reposted it. The first occurrence of the image now mentions that it is in the public domain because the copyright expired. If that's the reason it was removed originally I understand chess.com's POV.

I also saw a very long thread of "chess art" disappear from these forums, and it might have been for the same reason.

Brendan_UK

@vickalan You know this actually happened which makes it even more offensive, show some respect, you've already been warned to remove it, it still exists in your https://www.chess.com/forum/view/chess960-chess-variants/looking-for-opponents-games?page=3

So please remove it from this #1, it has no place on Help & Support, if it's still here when I check back shortly I'll have no option but to report.

You've already been given a chance!

[Update] I reported this on July 26 & the response was "We’ll review, and remove any images we find as too graphic for our site".

Unfortunately hanging is a common form of suicide, so this would be particularly distressing for any member that has lost a loved one in this way, if you cared about this then you would at least remove it from this Help & Support section here on your #1.

I personally havent lost anyone this way, but my ex who lost her brother has.

(Aug 16): I'm sending you a copy of this #11 to make sure you get this message, please do the right thing & remove it from your #1 here: https://www.chess.com/forum/view/help-support/text-and-images-removed-by-moderators-with-no-reason-given?page=1#last_comment

JustOneUSer
It's been here for 17 hours, chances are the staff already saw it and chose not to remove it this time
JustOneUSer
Anyway he may be using the app and be unable to remove it.
notmtwain
SuperSam1 wrote:

Lol. They wouldn't mute or ban vickalan. He's too valuable a member. He pretty much runs the variants section of the forums.

I don't play variants often but often see posts made here asserting that it is very difficult to find games. How popular do you think that the variants really are?  

Right now, there are only 4 variants games going on in Live Chess.

DrSpudnik

He seems to have a fixation on killing people for religious purposes. The picture and his profile pic are indicative of a disturbed personality.

RonaldJosephCote

 I agree with Brendon, its offensive and not very pleasant. It doesn't portray the site in a good light.

notmtwain

Two hours later there are only 2 variant games being played. Out of the 64,569 players now online, only 4 are playing variants.

SuperSam1

Are you counting the Bulldog with Witch, Bulldog with Dwarf, Chess on an Infinite plane and all the other variants in the variants forum?

notmtwain
SuperSam1 wrote:

Are you counting the Bulldog with Witch, Bulldog with Dwarf, Chess on an Infinite plane and all the other variants in the variants forum?

No. Those are not being counted.

In the meantime, the number of actual variant games being played in live chess has reached 5, a new high.

 

Lagomorph
DrSpudnik wrote:

He seems to have a fixation on killing people for religious purposes. The picture and his profile pic are indicative of a disturbed personality.

 

Careful, he may put a hex on you