My compositions (critisize me as much as possible)

Sort:
pelly13
ajttja schreef:

1. Qxg6(this is correct) - Rf6 2. Qxf5 (by scottrf)- Qe8 3.??

The biting way you answered my first try (forcing a specific textual format) has put me off enough to not engage any further.

apostolis1

For no1

1.g8=Q Nd6 and 2. Qc8

Scottrf
ajttja wrote:

if you want a legal position scottrf then do the first one.

I don't understand the problem with that. Just don't create stalemate and the obvious moves win.

watcha

1. Qxg6 Ba7+ 2. Kh2 Rh5+ 3. Qxh5 Qd7

1. Qxg6 Rf2 2. Bxf2+

I don't see clear mate in either position.

shepi13

First position g8Q Nd6 Qd8 Nb7 Qc8 Nc5 Kg2 mates, no? Everything else looks winning too, though.

watcha

The first is mate in 9. This can be checked by comp.

The second one is interesting though. It is an illegal position so it can't be fed into my comp.

watcha

Here is the solution for the first one:

Please answer my question on the second one.

BigDoggProblem
ajttja wrote:

the second one is mate in six for white,

Sorry, but my comp says there is no mate in 6.

TBentley

Here's some possible continuations for the second one according to Houdini 1.5: Wink

0. ... Kf6 Nxc3 Kh5 2.Bxg6+ 2.Kf3+ Bc6+ 3.Rd3+ Kf6+ Bxb4 Nxb5 Bxd3

1.Kf3 Bc6+ 2.Kd4 Kf6 3.Kxc6+ Kd5+ Kb6+ Nxc3+ Q2xa3+ d6+ Ne4+

1.Kf3 Kf6 Bc6+ Nxc3+ Kh5+ 3.Bxg6+ 4.Rd3+ Kf6+ Bxb4 Nxb5 Bxd3

ProfessorProfesesen

ok you asked for it: you misspelled criticise. What is wrong with you?

ajttja

for problem two i meant to put a knight, not a bishop on b8. watcha, if white promotes to a queen black will just move his knight between c8 and d6(or betweens c8 and e7) if white takes it then it will be stalemate.

BigDoggProblem
ajttja wrote:

for problem two i meant to put a knight, not a bishop on b8. watcha, if white promotes to a queen black will just move his knight between c8 and d6(or betweens c8 and e7) if white takes it then it will be stalemate.

With bNb8 there is a cook found by comp: 1.Qxc7!

ajttja

i think white can still hold a draw, they will get a fortress i think.

AwesomeCheckl

Solution of first on promote the pawn to a knight black has to play Nd6 then we play Ne7 again black has to move the knight and whereever he moves it Nc8 is mate

SacrifycedStoat
For the first puzzle, it’s an analysis board, not a puzzle.