I remade my pfp
Sort:
Apr 27, 2025
0
#4
Allan0818 wrote:
I like 1st better.
I inquire as to the reasons behind your opinion
Apr 27, 2025
0
#5
They are both nice, but I prefer the first one more. The second seems a bit too goofy to me
Apr 27, 2025
0
#6
I cannot comprehend how the 2D badly-made version is less goofy than the 3D shaded one I put effort into
Apr 27, 2025
0
#7
Nate_Pi wrote:
Nice shading work on the second one
the first one has a nice cartoony feel but both are good imo
Thank you, this is actually my first time doing shading on something that isn't a sphere
First is better
Apr 27, 2025
0
#10
They’re both good! I admire the work put into both, but I gotta admit, the first hits harder for me
Apr 27, 2025
0
#11
Crazy amount of people who prefer the one that looks like it was made by kindergartener
Prob the second one, but the top of the rook is a bit weird
Ye
Before:
After: