Before:
After:
I inquire as to the reasons behind your opinion
They are both nice, but I prefer the first one more. The second seems a bit too goofy to me
I cannot comprehend how the 2D badly-made version is less goofy than the 3D shaded one I put effort into
Nice shading work on the second one
the first one has a nice cartoony feel but both are good imo
Thank you, this is actually my first time doing shading on something that isn't a sphere
#7 idk, points of view
They’re both good! I admire the work put into both, but I gotta admit, the first hits harder for me
Crazy amount of people who prefer the one that looks like it was made by kindergartener
Prob the second one, but the top of the rook is a bit weird
Remade it again bc I can
Hmmmm
Before:
After: