Something about wishes

Sort:
Avatar of Martux09

So I've been thinking about the whole concept of wishes and stuff and I came across this paradox.

What happens if a genie grants both me and a mate a wish at the exact same time and we both say smth that the other doesn't want to happen.

For example I say "I don't want do be friends with my mate" and they say "I want to be friends with martux (aka me)".

Would any of us get their wish granted and if so why? 

Avatar of LJGoomba

My brain...

Avatar of M0lten_Knight
This is why genies and wishes that guaranteed come true immediately don’t exist
Avatar of M0lten_Knight
#4 just the paradox of saying “this statement is a lie” but with Pinocchio in it for apparently no reason
Avatar of BasixWhiteBoy

Depends on who the genie likes more.

Avatar of Martux09
xtreme2020 wrote:
#4 just the paradox of saying “this statement is a lie” but with Pinocchio in it for apparently no reason

There's a similar one on "El Quijote" about a village who only lets ppl in if they say the truth about where they're going and hangs them if they dont. A man goes up to the village entrance and gets asked where he's going to, which he replies "I'm gonna go die hung by yall for lying".

Avatar of Martux09
BasixWhiteBoy wrote:

Depends on who the genie likes more.

We're both equally sexy and smart.

Avatar of M0lten_Knight
#7 what did the villagers end up doing? Or does it not say
Avatar of Martux09
xtreme2020 wrote:
#7 what did the villagers end up doing? Or does it not say

They let the man enter the village, stating that in these cases we have to decide protecting life and avoiding death.

Avatar of Puzeic

the wishes cancel themselves out. You go back to the situation before the wishes. You wasted your wishes tho

Avatar of Martux09

bump

Avatar of RabbitRover

(Oop, looks like I decided to stalk this thread. Idk why I didn't just answer lol)

Ig in your example, you would stop being their friend, but they would still be yours 🙃

But I suppoooose under different circumstances, they'd cancel each other out, non?

So you'd just be wasting your wishes.

Avatar of RabbitRover

Actually, I know a joke similar.

Three friends are stuck on a desert island, and they find a genie lamp. So they pick it up and rub it, and out pop the genie.

He tells the friends, since there are three of you, I'll give you each one wish.

The first friend immediately asks to be sent home, the genie snaps his fingers and the friend teleports to his house.

The second friend says, well, I wish I could be sent straight to the restaurant in my town. The genie snaps his fingers, and he teleports away.

The genie turns to the third friend, and asks, well?

The third friend thinks for a moment. And he looks around and sees that he is the last one and feels lonely. So he tells the genie: I wish I had my friends back.

Avatar of RabbitRover

I am not very good at telling jokes 🫠

Avatar of Martux09
RabbitRover wrote:

Actually, I know a joke similar.

Three friends are stuck on a desert island, and they find a genie lamp. So they pick it up and rub it, and out pop the genie.

He tells the friends, since there are three of you, I'll give you each one wish.

The first friend immediately asks to be sent home, the genie snaps his fingers and the friend teleports to his house.

The second friend says, well, I wish I could be sent straight to the restaurant in my town. The genie snaps his fingers, and he teleports away.

The genie turns to the third friend, and asks, well?

The third friend thinks for a moment. And he looks around and sees that he is the last one and feels lonely. So he tells the genie: I wish I had my friends back.

well in my example, both wishes are wished at the exact same time, making it a paradox

whereas in yours, they happen at different times, one having the "i was first" advantage