The greatest quarterback of all-time

EN-mapquestboy

Who is the greatest quarterback of all-time? Mine is Joe Montana. Let the debate begin!

EN-viv4jake

lol

Master_Kaina

gr8choice! Cool (@HurricaneTroll: notice this forum is in Off Topic)

EN-viv4jake

Jerry Rice.

CoachLM

Statistically it's Joe Montana.  But my Indiana upbringing tells me Peyton Manning is the bees knees.  

DrStrangeLuft

There are a lot of Great quarterbacks to consider. The best one now playing is Peyton Manning in my humble opinion, who is a certain Hall-of-Famer. There have been a lot of great ones. Joe Montana is certainly right at the top as is Steve Young, John Elway and Brett Favre. Earlier Players like Johnny Unitas, Roger Staubach, Bob Griese, Bart Starr, Kenny Stabler, Y.A. Title, Sonny Jurgenson, and Joe Namath deserve consideration also.  In the past 20 years I would probably agree with Joe Montana. The trouble is it is hard to compare quarterbacks of different eras, because playing conditions were different.

losingmove

Stan Gable...

Hands down the best

EN-mapquestboy

I meant NFL.

bigpoison

Morphy!  Or, maybe, Trent Dilfer.

EN-mapquestboy

Trent Dilfer???

bigpoison

Not Dilfer?  Eric Hipple?  Ummm...who was that big, tall southpaw who threw sidearm?  Oh, yeah, Scott Mitchell!

EN-mapquestboy
viv4jake wrote:

Jerry Rice.

He was the greatest NFL player who ever lived. The greatest WR, not QB.

EN-mapquestboy
HurricaneMichael1 wrote:

Good lord what the heck is this doing in a chess site for heavon's sake?

It's just a debate. That's all.

bigpoison
mapquestboy wrote:
viv4jake wrote:

Jerry Rice.

He was the greatest NFL player who ever lived. The greatest WR, not QB.

Nobody ever loves the linemen.  Bruce Matthews!

EN-mapquestboy

Bruce Matthews was one of the greatest offensive linemen of all time. Anthony Munoz was the greatest offensive lineman to ever play in the NFL.

EN-mapquestboy

Scott Mitchell???????? Only had 1995 season.

AlCzervik

Jim Otto.

EN-mapquestboy

?

bigpoison

Us kids always called him "Buckshot".

EN-mapquestboy

Yeah, Jim Otto was the best CENTER who ever played the game.