Just realized he is from Canada and if French Canadian that is not fair question. Plus in the Southern part of the US some call jelly... syrup as they put in on their pancakes. And the rich call jelly something else as i have seen that "Grey Poupon" forget how to say it so i sounded it.
what letter am i thinking of

I was not sure Strawberry was a pie!
But i thought of Rasberry just as i finished typing up my comment # 734.
R
It could any number depending on culture. If he is just speaking in general then either i or PinkiePieCrazy123 won.

Easy way is to play games consistantly. I say 70% of my trophies have come that way. Maybe be larger as i lost track. I know i like to have certain tropies and more of 1 particular trophy.

RB and pinkie ill give you both a trophy for your cleverness the real number is still out there everyone can guess 3 more times

Do they have an IHOP in Canada ? As IHOP has all kinds of jelly.
Hmmm JELLO I think they have lemon
Lemon Marang (think i said correct)
But i now understand it the clue as my line of thinking is a little off.

I think i have it!
I was playing a word game about a year ago. And i named 200 pies and cakes. Word Association was the name of the game, just came to me. They were getting so sick of me. I got them with Orange cakes as they had a hard time getting the next word to use. Looked @ food in kitchen... and saw there was Orange flavor.
So my choice would be
O

Hehehehe i already called that one!
Blueberry came right to my mind when he said smell. I like the spell of anything blueberry.
No sign of that trophy he mentioned yet.
Only jelly that smells like pie would be Blueberry.
So that would make it
B