Why is there no take back option?

Sort:
Avatar of Gatri51

I've had too many games where a player has dropped a piece unintentionally in the wrong place making the rest of the game pointless. I usually offer a draw but I would much rather have the option to offer a take back so we can continue enjoying our game. Has chess.com ever considered this option?

 

 

By "unintentionally dropping a piece", I didn't mean a mistake in strategy, I meant a person most likely playing on a phone or tablet, who intended to place a piece on one square, but accidently put it somehwere else due to a hardware error, or perhaps lag, which has happened to me. Judging by these comments it seems that quite a few people still wouldn't want this option so that they can still claim a victory in this manner. Is it really worth winnng if the game wasn't enjoyable?

Avatar of nightjumpper

Haha yes I completely understand what your mean. If chess.com would implement this feature into their system it would be really appreciated. 

Avatar of JRTK73

It's a good thing to have for teaching purposes as well. As long as both players agree with the takeback I don't see the problem.

Avatar of baddogno

There is a takeback option for correspondence chess and it is useful in a teaching situation.  

 Rated: YesNoTakeback

Avatar of Joseph-S

 An option to trade sides would be interesting too.  For example, if you were playing a much lower rated player and got a piece, you could trade sides and let the lower rated player try to win with the extra piece.

Avatar of Beren_Camlost

I thought that we are trying to win. I would go join the Bronies if I wanted to make friends.

Avatar of blackrabbitto

Gatri, you are so generous! Frightfully sporting, though.

Avatar of SJFG

If the player seems decent (I know - usually how would you know?) and the move wasn't a capture, you could offer to make a move that does nothing, have him move his piece back, and then you move your piece back.  I did this to a guy... twice! He told me I was nice. Smile Then a game or two later I made a mouse slip and he chatted that he wasn't a nice guy Tongue OutCry

Avatar of DrSpudnik

No takesies-backsies! I called it.

Avatar of beerpatzer

I think there are takebacks in "online chess" on this site, as opposed to "live chess"... 

 

In live chess, the very act of offering a takeback would put you in disadvantage because it takes a 1-2 second to click on the button. In fact, much of bullet and blitz strategy depends on your opponent making a stupid mistake...  Some people love it for exactly that reason... You would probably hate it, and I kinda agree... :D

Avatar of AaronShaverPDX

I'm glad there's no takeback option. I can only imagine how trolls and cheaters would abuse it. And it would slow down games.

Avatar of tonightatsix
AaronShaverPDX wrote:

I'm glad there's no takeback option.

+1

Avatar of prakhar9998

I think it should be there but should be allowed only if both players agreed.

Avatar of denner

Why is there no take back option ? Because this is CHESS... Not Candyland.

Avatar of kleelof
Joseph-S wrote:

 An option to trade sides would be interesting too.  For example, if you were playing a much lower rated player and got a piece, you could trade sides and let the lower rated player try to win with the extra piece.

Nice idea. Especially for teaching.

Avatar of Lucidish_Lux

If you want to do that, play a game on an analysis board in live chess. Just treat it as a game board, but you can actually make any move (legal or not) that you want. That's how I did lessons.

Avatar of Sossitch

The problem is the jerks that will get furious and berate you if you don't offer the takeback after they blunder, you can always just have a rematch instead.

Avatar of beerpatzer
AaronShaverPDX wrote:

I'm glad there's no takeback option. I can only imagine how trolls and cheaters would abuse it. And it would slow down games.

I don't think cheaters need the takeback option... That's the point.  And the person offerred a takeback is under no obligation to accept, which also eliminates trolls... Thus, your comment is completely beside the point.

Avatar of kleelof

How about a 'takebeer' button?

Avatar of IpswichMatt
Beren_Camlost wrote:

I thought that we are trying to win. I would go join the Bronies if I wanted to make friends.

You should do that - maybe they could give you a hand with your spelling.

Smile