Bad Day For Best Players In St. Louis
After writing in these pages yesterday about the successes of the three prohibitive favorites, they all struggled in round three of the 2015 U.S. Championship and U.S. Women's Championship.
GM Irina Krush lost her first game at the championship in four years, GM Wesley So lost as White to the youngest player in the field, and GM Hikaru Nakamura allowed a last-minute salvo to spoil his win. Collectively, the group went 0.5/3, ensuring the $64,000 "Fischer Prize" is safe for another year.
"It's a lot of fun to see chaos," GM Maurice Ashley said while summing up the day's action.
"I probably didn't analyze the opening too deeply," So said of his loss to GM Sam Sevian, the youngest grandmaster in the world. So's former teammate concurred.
"I think he made a very bad opening choice," GM Ray Robson said. "It plays to Sevian's style, it's not a very good line in general. It's just a mistake."
So reached for the right word but came up with the same one. "It was a mistake going for such a dangerous line without knowing all the subtleties...These (young) players are born with computers. Sam probably when he was six. I started using computers when I was 10!"
Still, after pitching a knight to decimate Black's kingside and collecting enough pawns to fill a Volkswagen, So looked to be inches from a 3-0 start in his first U.S. Championship. The only problem? All those open lines were filled with Black pieces, which were primed on his own king.
So faced forced mate in six when he finally capitulated. "I was told he's very good at mating people!" So said.
Analysis by GM Ben Finegold coming soon:
When did Sevian know he would win? "After ...Qxg5 I knew." So offered a draw one move later, which Sevian said he "knew he couldn't take." Perhaps because he was about to beat the world number five, Sevian's body began shaking in the final moves. He said he had to remind himself it was just another guy, and Black was winning against anyone sitting in the opposite chair.
So "plummeted" back to world number eight, right back where he began the event.
As for Nakamura, he played the longest game of the day. For most of it, he could have expected to take over sole first place. Better for most of the game against GM Gata Kamsky, a late oversight cost him a half-point and created another tie at the top (this time with Robson, who won today to also move to 2.5/3).
So what happened? Kamsky said he didn't expect 2...e6 (instead a King's Indian). "I didn't prepare for this tournament much because of some things going on." Later, his pieces were in solitary confinement for hours until the resource 55. Nf7?! appeared. It still loses but gave practical chances!
"The last few moves, I was just shuffling pieces around, waiting for him to finish me off," Kamsky explained. "I was really proud when I found Nf7."
Both 55...Qc6 and 55...Qc5 still win (the computer even seems to think 55...Kxf7 wins, but only a masochist would consider the recommended ridiculous lines where Black's king walks to the middle with the assistance of his two bishops).
Instead Nakamura offered his queen but White can escape with some funny knight hopping. The final position is an aesthetically pleasing fortress, but that's small consolation for leaving a half-point on the floor. The live transmission briefly showed 1-0 before correctly displaying that the draw was the result.
Analysis by GM Ben Finegold:
Kamsky's unbeaten streak at the championship ran to 24 games. The last man to take him out? Nakamura in 2012, also as Black.
Speaking of unbeaten streaks, Krush had not lost in St. Louis since 2011, having won three straight titles without defeats. That all ended today versus tournament newcomer IM Nazi Paikidze, whose accurate temporary piece sac created central pawns that steamrolled the six-time champ.
The former Georgian star recently married an American and began studies at the University of Maryland, Baltimore County. Some of Paikidze's notions of life in the U.S. turned out false: "The typical stereotypes are not true -- Americans are so friendly."
She said the Georgian Championship was a little stronger (her best finish was second), but there was one major difference -- no press ("I was very nervous about the media"). Paikidze was told at the players meeting to expect interviews, so she had to "prep" how to handle that too.
One thing that helped her feel at home? IM Rusa Goletiani, another Georgian native. The two are generationally different and had never met before this week, but they eagerly spoke their native tongue to each other. A quick language lesson: according to Goletiani, "nazi" means "soft" in Georgian and is pronounced like the rapper "Nas" with a long "e" at the end.
Paikidze is strong enough to qualify for the U.S. National Team, but she must not leave the country while waiting for her green card to be processed. Consequently, she will miss the Women's World Team Championship later this month. "It would be an honor to play for the U.S." she said.
Time to talk about the "field," which has caught up to the pre-tournament favorites. Let's go back to Goletiani, who has used some good fortune to springboard to the top. She won today and is tied for the lead at 2.5/3 with fellow winner WGM Katerina Nemcova. As previously reported, Goletiani survived an abysmal position to salvage an opening-round draw (against Nemcova), and yesterday she won a drawn ending. Before showing her win today, let's back up to yesterday and show a Troitsky-esque resource her opponent missed:
Back to today, WIM Viktorija's Ni's husband and former U.S. Champion GM Yury Shulman came to town, but he could only look on as Goletiani's knight on d3 spoiled the reunion. Of course, Shulman also served as Goletiani's coach for the U.S. women's team, so maybe the game was really Shulman-Shulman?!
For her thoughts on her successful return to high-level chess, here's an exclusive interview.
Nemcova also ascended to 2.5/3 after youngster WIM Annie Wang spoiled a solid position by allowing White's rooks to break through. After that Black's position collapsed expeditiously.
"Girls don't have so many drawish results; they play to win," Nemcova said as tournament commentator WGM Jennifer Shahade half laughed and half cringed. This week's small sample size: The ladies have produced only five draws in 18 games (28 percent); the men eight of 16 (50 percent).
Nemcova recently graduated from the University of Texas at Brownsville and is on the Webster University team while completing her graduate studies in public relations. She said being around GM Susan Polgar and all of her grandmaster teammates is great practice. "There are many stronger opponents waiting for me."
In other action, scoreless WGM Tatev Abrahamyan removed her bagel by taking out upstart NM Apurva Virkud. "I won a chess game!" Abrahamyan said facetiously.
Besides Nakamura, Goletiani and Nemcova, the last member of the 2.5-point club is GM Ray Robson.
Chess mortals might be scared by White's attack, but Robson held it together and won with a fast counterattack.
Chess.com caught up with Robson and asked him about wide-ranging subjects like declining the World Team Championships and why his parents moved to Myanmar. Here's the video interview:
Lastly, GM Varuzhan Akobian was left frustrated again. Before today's game, he explained that he knew the improvement to his round two game versus Nakamura but didn't play it. Today, GM Timur Gareev's opening was more flamboyant than his shirt. After 1. d4 d6 2. Nf3 h6?! Akobian was only able to muster a draw.
Tomorrow's anticipated battle between Nakamura and So might have lost a little perfect-score luster, but their second-career meeting looks to be the first of many in St. Louis. They've played much more if you venture outside of classical chess, including a 10-point shellacking by Nakamura in a recent Chess.com Death Match.
Tomorrow's round four starts at 1 p.m. Central (GMT -6). Live commentary can be found at www.chess.com/tv.
2015 U.S. Championship | Pairings for Round 4
| Table | White | Score | Rating | Black | Score | Rating |
| 1 | GM Troff, Kayden W | 1.5 | 2532 | GM Shankland, Samuel L | 1 | 2661 |
| 2 | GM Sevian, Samuel | 1.5 | 2531 | GM Naroditsky, Daniel | 0.5 | 2633 |
| 3 | GM Nakamura, Hikaru | 2.5 | 2798 | GM So, Wesley | 2 | 2788 |
| 4 | GM Gareev, Timur | 1 | 2604 | GM Kamsky, Gata | 1.5 | 2683 |
| 5 | GM Robson, Ray | 2.5 | 2656 | GM Akobian, Varuzhan | 1.5 | 2622 |
| 6 | GM Onischuk, Alexander | 1.5 | 2665 | GM Holt, Conrad | 1 | 2530 |
---
2015 U.S. Women's Championship | Pairings for Round 4
| Table | White | Score | Rating | Black | Score | Rating |
| 1 | WCM Virkud, Apurva | 1.5 | 2132 | GM Krush, Irina | 1.5 | 2477 |
| 2 | IM Goletiani, Rusudan | 2.5 | 2311 | IM Paikidze, Nazi | 2 | 2333 |
| 3 | WGM Sharevich, Anna | 1 | 2267 | WIM Ni, Viktorija | 0.5 | 2188 |
| 4 | WIM Wang, Annie | 1 | 1901 | WGM Foisor, Sabina-Francesca | 1.5 | 2235 |
| 5 | FM Melekhina, Alisa | 1.5 | 2235 | WGM Nemcova, Katerina | 2.5 | 2279 |
| 6 | WGM Abrahamyan, Tatev | 1 | 2322 | WFM Yu, Jennifer R | 1.5 | 2180 |
---
2015 U.S. Championship | Standings After Round 3
| Rank | Name | Score | Rating | TPR |
| 1 | GM Nakamura, Hikaru | 2.5 | 2798 | 2885 |
| 2 | GM Robson, Ray | 2.5 | 2656 | 2849 |
| 3 | GM So, Wesley | 2 | 2788 | 2733 |
| 4 | GM Kamsky, Gata | 1.5 | 2683 | 2663 |
| 5 | GM Onischuk, Alexander | 1.5 | 2665 | 2597 |
| 6 | GM Akobian, Varuzhan | 1.5 | 2622 | 2644 |
| 7 | GM Troff, Kayden W | 1.5 | 2532 | 2651 |
| 8 | GM Sevian, Samuel | 1.5 | 2531 | 2698 |
| 9 | GM Shankland, Samuel L | 1 | 2661 | 2576 |
| 10 | GM Gareev, Timur | 1 | 2604 | 2481 |
| 11 | GM Holt, Conrad | 1 | 2530 | 2561 |
| 12 | GM Naroditsky, Daniel | 0.5 | 2633 | 2387 |
---
2015 U.S. Women's Championship | Standings After Round 3
| Rank | Name | Score | Rating | TPR |
| 1 | IM Goletiani, Rusudan | 2.5 | 2311 | 2507 |
| 2 | WGM Nemcova, Katerina | 2.5 | 2279 | 2433 |
| 3 | IM Paikidze, Nazi | 2 | 2333 | 2391 |
| 4 | GM Krush, Irina | 1.5 | 2477 | 2252 |
| 5 | FM Melekhina, Alisa | 1.5 | 2235 | 2211 |
| 6 | WGM Foisor, Sabina-Francesca | 1.5 | 2235 | 2352 |
| 7 | WFM Yu, Jennifer R | 1.5 | 2180 | 2134 |
| 8 | WCM Virkud, Apurva | 1.5 | 2132 | 2297 |
| 9 | WGM Abrahamyan, Tatev | 1 | 2322 | 1971 |
| 10 | WGM Sharevich, Anna | 1 | 2267 | 2106 |
| 11 | WIM Wang, Annie | 1 | 1901 | 2128 |
| 12 | WIM Ni, Viktorija | 0.5 | 2188 | 2101 |
Previous reports:
- Preview: 2015 U.S. Championship Youngest, Strongest In History
- Opening Ceremony: U.S. Championship Opens, Shabalov Inducted
- Round 1: Leaders Challenged In U.S. Championships Openers
- Round 2: Top Seeds Nakamura, So, Krush Cruise In Round 2
Company Contact and News Accreditation:
- Email: Mike@chess.com
- Phone: 1 (800) 318-2827
- Address: PO Box 60400 Palo Alto, CA 94306
Mike Klein began playing chess at the age of four in Charlotte, NC. In 1986, he lost to Josh Waitzkin at the National Championship featured in the movie "Searching for Bobby Fischer." A year later, Mike became the youngest member of the very first All-America Chess Team, and was on the team a total of eight times. In 1988, he won the K-3 National Championship, and eventually became North Carolina's youngest-ever master. In 1996, he won clear first for under-2250 players in the top section of the World Open. Mike has taught chess full-time for a dozen years in New York City and Charlotte, with his students and teams winning many national championships. He now works at Chess.com as a Senior Journalist and at ChessKid.com as the Chief Chess Officer. In 2012, 2015, and 2018, he was awarded Chess Journalist of the Year by the Chess Journalists of America. He has also previously won other awards from the CJA such as Best Tournament Report, and also several writing awards for mainstream newspapers. His chess writing and personal travels have now brought him to more than 85 countries.
