Forums

Caro-Kann Opening vs French Defense

Sort:
Lalit0007

Which is better Caro-Kann or French?

Lalit0007

Caro-Kann is better

jack_iles

they both have pros and cons

Lalit0007

In french the bishop stays block

SilentKnighte5

Green.

ilikecapablanca

French orange. As opposed to the darker English orange.

TalsKnight

Caro Kann produces more interesting games then the French. In the French you may end up with more boring positions ie "Exchange " for example. But thats just my opinion. I gave up on the French because the positions just bored me to death !

Equiv

In the caro kann your lightsquare bishop isn't sad . but they both are good .

adumbrate

French is the best opening of all black openings against 1. e4. I'm telling you.

LightningBoltOfZeus

All the french is is an mediocre try to get an queen's gambit tarrasch variation,without the e pawns.Either way i use an marcozy bind to shut both of the french and caro up.



adumbrate
Black wins later.
adumbrate

For example:



LightningBoltOfZeus
GreenCastleBlock

Green is definitely better.

adumbrate

umm, Bc4 is bad. To answer your line:



adumbrate
GreenCastleBlock wrote:

Green is definitely better.

 

c4 e6 e4 e5? is bad as white is up an tempo in for example this variation:

 



GreenCastleBlock
skotheim2 wrote:
GreenCastleBlock wrote:

Green is definitely better.

c4 e6 e4 e5? is bad as white is up an tempo in for example this variation:

Incorrect.  The variation that you posted is so poor for White strategically Black can afford to go in a tempo down and argue equality.  If I were Black after 1.e4 e5 2.c4 I would already be thinking about playing for advantage after 2...Bc5 or 2...Nc6.

adumbrate

eh example:



GreenCastleBlock
skotheim2 wrote:

eh example:

I do not agree with your conclusion.  After 5...Bc5 White cannot demonstrate any advantage there.  The c2-c4 is a negative move in your Scotch Game.

LightningBoltOfZeus

wow such retaliation:P