They're both great sets and I'm sure they both play very well. If there's one thing I've learned, then it's that these sets are very hard to label if there is no explicit label or name on the box (certainly with my limited experience)
But in the end, a label doesn't make them prettier or better quality.
Regular members may be aware of various posts where I thought I had a Lardy but alas, no - so I called it Lardy’ish. More recently, I acquired a confirmed Lardy Size 6 which we think is from the 70’s or 80’s. My gut feel is the Lardy’ish is older - it’s hard to explain why but I think it’s the patina and carving.
I thought I would bring the pieces and conversation into one thread. Here’s some initial shots. In future, I might add some measurements, weight comparisons and clearer photos. In truth, I like them both.
First, the Lardy’ish
Now the Lardy
Below - the Lardy’ish on the left and the Lardy on the right.