e4 Vs d4

Sort:
kindaspongey

Well, at any rate, you do not prefer 3 Nc3.

my137thaccount
kindaspongey wrote:

Well, at any rate, you do not prefer 3 Nc3.

Indeed

Lion_XVI

Never trust a post with no pic...

Example... DeardrieSky.

DrSpudnik
Destroyer942 wrote:

Many people claim the Sicilian is a strong response to e4. However in my experience, one has to be a strong player to use it effectively.

True. I used to look for anti-Sicilians to use to throw my opponents, but eventually gave that up and went to the main-lines of the Open Sicilian. Most people who wield this weapon are no good and think that the opening alone will save them. A laughable idea.

Lion_XVI

Groan...

RedEye12
1.e4 1. d4 and 1. c4 all have different advantages. e4 frees the bishop, queen and a square for the knight. d4 controls both c5 and e5 and c4 controls the d5 square.
ZapsPlays

 

EthanShaffer111
Yigor wrote:
BobbyTalparov wrote:
Yigor wrote:

1. d4 is clearly better!  The reason is simple: there is no counter-attacking system as good as Sicilian.  Though, sorry to inform U, but for players with tiny ratings (below Elo 3000) it doesn't matter. 

*cough* The King's Indian Defense *cough*

 

Your coughing shows that the suggestion is rhetorical and U know very well that it's not as good as Sicilian.  No kidding, KID is kinda cheesy, calling it a "counter-attack" would be an exaggeration. 

You're just a 1.d4 fanboy with no skill.

DrSpudnik

The KID is a counterattack, as is the French, Caro-Kan and the Sicilian. Black either defends a symmetrical position (e4/e5 or d4/d5) or tries to counterattack the center.

charles749

I love e4!!!!,the wild sharp tactical play entices me

beginner7196

"1.d4 is better, because the d4-pawn is defended, while the e4-pawn is not - it perishes quickly. The d4-pawn is more solid." - Bobby Fischer in retirement. 

RivertonKnight

I think 1 Nf3 is best!

JackRoach

E4 versus d4... Hmm...

I'd say versus is best.

JackRoach
beginner7196 wrote:

"1.d4 is better, because the d4-pawn is defended, while the e4-pawn is not - it perishes quickly. The d4-pawn is more solid." - Bobby Fischer in retirement. 

The e pawn doesn't perish quickly, unless you mean it trades quickly if black wants to.

 

Warrior_GOLD

I prefer D4 because thermonuclear corncobs

shadow1414

@Rivertonknight #54 I agree!

DerekDHarvey

Play them both if your opponent lets you.

 

DerekDHarvey

One leads to a slow game, the other doesn't.

 

huddsblue

e4. If it's good enough for Bobby Fischer it's good enough for me.

spell_part_backwards

If supercomputers far above the best humans cant decide on one or the other as definitively better, it's safe to assume they are effectively the same.