I don’t think you should add more openings, because that’s useless. Why have 2 openings with white? What’s the point? I have a pet opening if I ever get bored, but that’s the farthest I’ll go. No point in studying 2 openings when only 1 of them will be useful every game.
I think at 1600 you should begin to study some opening lines. You’ve probably played thousands of games to get from where you are to 1600, so just start to take a look at some common lines and understand the ideas that come from your opening (you’ll probably have a good idea because you’ve been playing the opening, but extra knowledge doesn’t hurt)
Be careful not to focus all your time on openings, though. As mentioned, tactics decide games at the -2000 level. This is just to get you out of the opening comfortably.
Thanks to everyone for the feedback. It's really helpful!!! It confirms my suspicion that, at least on my level, "less is more." Now, a question for the future. If I manage to eventually achieve a rating like 1600, do you guys feel I should THEN add more openings/defenses, or stick with the recommendations that have already been given in this thread? THANKS AGAIN FOR YOUR HELP!!!!