Is the Traxler Variation Unsound?

Sort:
Robert_New_Alekhine
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 is without reason:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 hit on a bright idea:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

kiloNewton

please stop jokes & analyse how it could be applied in bullet chess!

Robert_New_Alekhine

IT WAS REFUTED ON PAGE 3!

The_Ghostess_Lola

I like the Wilkes-Barre.

NBKXX
Veganomnomnom wrote:

Yes, because one move is proof of anything...the advantage is rather small. How do you improve on Anand's loss to Beliavsky in Linares 1991?

Schussler annoted this game for chessbase: After 14.Rg3 White was much better, and after 20.Rg5 White was even winning.

Polar_Bear

Tarrasch understood 4. Ng5?! is not very good move, but he didn't know exactly why. Today, we know: black can play 4. ... Bc5! (Traxler).

lolurspammed

Bc5 is more of a gift than a refutation.

Scottrf
Polar_Bear wrote:

Tarrasch understood 4. Ng5?! is not very good move, but he didn't know exactly why. Today, we know: black can play 4. ... Bc5! (Traxler).

Except that white is better of course.

Polar_Bear

In my (not alone) opinion, Traxler is 100% sound.

Yes, white may appear seemingly better, but has to defend accurately to secure a draw.

Robert_New_Alekhine

It definetly is, as we saw from page 1!

Polar_Bear

It is matter of taste. I used to play both and both give black enough for sacrificed material.

IMO, black should play 3. ... Nf6 and not 3. ... Bc5 to avoid Evans.

The real problem with black is that above certain level, 90% of white opponents prefer Ruy.

lolurspammed

Why avoid Evans? It's a playable opening but nothing to "avoid." I'm personally more afraid of a prepared fried liver player.

Robert_New_Alekhine

This is going slightly of topic.

ghostofmaroczy
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

Robert_New_Alekhine
ghostofmaroczy will stop dsying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

PPS2
Robert0905 wrote:
ghostofmaroczy will stop dsying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

Robert_New_Alekhine
PPS2 meant to write something but forgot what he wanted to write:
Robert0905 wrote:
ghostofmaroczy will stop dsying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

ghostofmaroczy
Robert0905 mistakenly thought PPS2 had anything to say when in reality, PPS2 knows the forum is closed:
PPS2 meant to write something but forgot what he wanted to write:
Robert0905 emphatically reiterated the closure of the forum:
ghostofmaroczy will stop saying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

Robert_New_Alekhine
ghostofmaroczy should stop saying nonsense in this forum, because this topic is closed, once and for aall.:
Robert0905 mistakenly thought PPS2 had anything to say when in reality, PPS2 knows the forum is closed:
PPS2 meant to write something but forgot what he wanted to write:
Robert0905 emphatically reiterated the closure of the forum:
ghostofmaroczy will stop saying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.

Robert_New_Alekhine
Robert0905 should stop posting in this method, as it gets very long.:
ghostofmaroczy should stop saying nonsense in this forum, because this topic is closed, once and for aall.:
Robert0905 mistakenly thought PPS2 had anything to say when in reality, PPS2 knows the forum is closed:
PPS2 meant to write something but forgot what he wanted to write:
Robert0905 emphatically reiterated the closure of the forum:
ghostofmaroczy will stop saying nonsense, because I will not reopen the forum:
Robert0905 will not reopen the forum:
ghostofmaroczy forgot that this forum is closed:
Robert0905 had closed the forum:
ghostofmaroczy realized what a smart person I am:
Robert0905 closed this forum:

No reason to post any more.

No true.