Suspicious behaviour in client blitz games

DMFW

On a couple of occasions recently I've seen some suspicious behaviour in blitz games played on the iPad client. I'd got myself to a winning position and the opponent appeared to abandon the game after my last move. I sit there waiting for them to time out. Their clock ticks and suddenly when it reaches zero my last move auto magically disappears as though I haven't made it and I'm the one that times out and loses! It's quite annoying... I understand that there can be comms issues so my move might not have been recorded but what makes me suspicious is that this always seems to happen when I've attained a won position and with no prior warning (e.g. Poor response times or anything) until that critical point. If I didn't know better It looks almost like the client has been spoofed into not accepting my next move so the server times me out) Of course this is a bit paranoid but even if it's all totally innocent why does my client show the opponents clock as ticking if it hasn't had an acknowledgement from the server of my move? That just seems like a software design issue. At the least there should be some signal that the client is guessing with the timer when clearly it is guessing here (guessing the server got my move without confirmation)... That would at least give some warning the game had problems and the reversal at the end wouldn't be such a shock (except I half expect it now). Unless of course someone really has figured a way to spoof the client.

Martin_Stahl

You got disconnected and your last move wasn't received by the server. For whatever reason, the app doesn't recognize that you get disconnected. Your opponent was sitting there thinking you stopped moving.

 

There are a lot of topics about this issue. The keep-alive code being used by the app (and even the web client) probably needs to be made a bit more robust.

DMFW

Yes, it makes sense. It would somehow be less disappointing if the client indicated in some way that it hadn't successfully received an acknowledgement from the server for your last move. It must know it is in this state for a long time, so perhaps just making the clock background for the opponent a different colour to indicate it is only provisionally reducing their time? I get that server communications will inevitably fail at some annoying time. I'd just like to know sooner than that sudden apparent reversal at the end.

santinojuico

it happened a lot of time to me too happy.png wondering if my opponent/s had anything to do with it.

 

forked_again

The same thing happened to me once and I made a thread about it.  I don't think my opponent had anything to do with it.  One thing you can do if you think it is happening is refresh your page.  That takes some time when you are playing blitz but i play rapidgames.

DamonevicSmithlov

Be suspicious. Be very suspicious.

 

It happened to me before too.