This is actually not at all a bad refutation of my idea. I still find The Vienna to be a solid defense but he does have some strange ideas like he literally recommended newer players to try The Scandinavian.
It can depend on which line of the Vienna you play. Overall, the Vienna is a decent opening. It's not white's most active choice though and doesn't put so much pressure on the opponent compared to the Italian or Spanish.
The Scandinavian is very dubious. There is no refutation but if you don't know what you're doing you can get into trouble as you are moving your queen around a lot in the opening and allow white perfect development for no real compensation.
It's more the silly gambits and sidelines that he teaches like a3 and b3 sicilians. These lines are somewhat playable but they are also not very good. They are basically just meant for bullying lower rated players lol.
But Samuel, who would you recommend?